“Guys, check this out!” I heard an excited yell.
My eye fluttered open. I immediately felt like I had been hit with a brick. My head throbbed and there wasn’t a single part of my body that didn’t feel thrashed. On top of that, my clothing was stiff and itchy, halfway between dry and wet. I felt cold and thus reached out to grab something warm. My hand caressed something plump and I squeezed.
“Mmm…” I heard a woman moan, and very slowly my brain began to realize I was squeezing a small piece of bare soft tissue.
During the night, I had fallen to the side, and my arm was wrapped around the woman next to me. My hand had ended up going up to her shirt, and I could feel her bare breast against my palm. As the memory of where I was and what happened the previous night came slamming home, I pulled my hand out of her shirt and jerked upright.
The realization that I had been feeling up Cara in front of everyone shot through me, but as I glanced down at the woman, it turned out to be my sister, Callie. Everyone else still appeared to be asleep, but some were starting to groggily move. Lana was sitting, but she was leaning away from me now, barely covered under the blanket. Somehow, I had ended tangled in the blankets and spooning Callie. I should have realized by her flat chest that it was my identical twin sister.
“Guys!” Cara poked her head into the cave from the entrance leading back into the crevice.
Callie woke up with a snort. When I had sat up, I took the blanket with me, completely exposing Callie in that vulnerable state. She was lying there with her shirt up, stopping just short of exposing a nipple. She wasn’t wearing a bra, but that was normal for my sister. Her shorts were so low the crevice of her pubic region could be seen. Her eyes fluttered open and then met mine.
“What?” She asked.
I looked away. Even though I had been groping her, she had been oblivious to it. The rest of my family only started jerking awake too over Cara’s words. I waited as everyone started waking up. I wanted to know what Cara was talking about, but I had morning wood, and the blanket was the only thing keeping me from exposing myself. When was the last time I had morning wood? It was almost like my release the previous night had kickstarted a libido that had been near death.
As that thought struck me, I couldn’t help but look up at Cara. She looked away as soon as our eyes met. Had she been looking at me? What we did last night, felt almost like a dream. However, her shirt was filthy and missing two buttons. Those were two buttons I had torn off. She didn’t button the button of her shirt because of that, and it splayed out, exposing her belly button and stomach. I felt a sudden desire to pull her into a kiss, but how could I do such a thing?
I didn’t even know how Cara felt about everything. It had all happened so suddenly. Would she tell someone? Was my peace on the island becoming a ticking time bomb? I had no clue.
My erection had calmed down by the time everyone was getting up, so I finally dropped the now dirty blanket and followed them out into the ravine. As I did so, I felt in my pocket to see the fire starter was still there. She had kept her promise. I let out a sigh. The leaves I had attempted to protect the area with had collapsed, and the little area was torn up. The running water from the day before was gone, and the plant was stripped of berries. I touched it only for Cassie to move up to me and whisper in my ear.
“I saw Aunt Sally come out and pocket them all just before the rain started.” She spoke quietly.
I gave a nod in response. I had complicated feelings when it came to that. Sally had assuredly planned to keep them all to herself, but they really might not have survived the storm if she didn’t. I discarded the empty vine that would no longer feed us, and that’s when I found what Cara wanted us to see. At the very edge of the ravine was a small hole that seemed to lead deeper in.
“What is this?” Sally yawned. “Is this why you woke me up?”
“When the lightning struck last night, it must have caused this hole to form,” Cara said, her eyes only briefly darting to me.
I suddenly had a growing suspicion about that lightning blast. It had happened just as we finished our love-making. The goddess had given me promises. Was this her way of meeting them? I sighed.
“Let’s see where it leads.” I began to crouch.
“No! Dad, I’ll go.” Cassie declared.
“We don’t know where it leads, or how far it goes.” Cassie declared. “I was so scared when you didn’t come back last night. I thought you and Aunt Cara were seriously hurt or struck by thunder. When I heard you were bitten by a snake, it was even worse. Dad, you’re too important. You can’t keep taking all the risks for us.”
Although her words were heartfelt, they only made me feel intense guilt. I could see Cara looking away as she spoke, unwilling to comment. After all, those times I had scared her had been times I was had been screwing around with Cara. I had made my daughter worried while having sex. No… we wouldn’t even have food or shelter if I hadn’t acted! I couldn’t blame myself… not entirely.
I wasn’t really worried too much. If this had been prepared by the Goddess, it shouldn’t be a trap. It still left me a bit anxious.
“If that’s the case… the smallest person should go.” Sally broke in. “They’d be the most mobile if something comes up.”
“Sm-smallest?” Cassie blinked, and then looked down to see the nice chest she had inherited from her mother before covering up with a blush.
“I-I don’t like snakes!” Callie cried out. “Do you think there are snakes?”
“That might be a bit smaller there, but you’re still too tall,” Sally dismissed her and turned to Sally, a smirk on her face. “She should go. Isn’t she the smallest?”
“Sally!” Mom admonished.
My family typically had small chests. We just weren’t blessed with large ones. Sally had the largest chest of her sisters, about the same size and mom, and liked to lord it over them. She’d take any opportunity to mock Val and Callie for it but now was not the time. I opened my mouth to shut her down when Val suddenly spoke up.
“I’ll do it!”
“Ah… Val… you don’t have to…” I didn’t want to force her, still a bit guilty about a few nights prior.
“No.” She shook her head. “I need to help out. We all have to do our part.”
She was the youngest, but she ended up being the one pushed into doing it thanks to Sally. I wasn’t worried, but I still didn’t like it. I crouched down close to the entrance.
“I’ll be right here if you need me.” I declared, only realizing how bad that sounded after saying that.
To my surprise, Val turned to me and smiled. “It’s because big brother is here that I feel I can.”
I blinked, but she didn’t give me time to dwell. She fell to all fours and then started to crawl through the hole. It was large enough for me to get through, but I’d have to crawl army style. My smaller sister could just do it on all fours. I watched as her butt waggled into the hole, and felt a twinge as I thought about that night where I came with my dick pushed up against that thing. A dark part of me suddenly wished I had gone farther when I had the chance.
I shook my head. That was the incest goddess talking. My association with her was done. I had done what she asked. I had fire, food, and water. Everything was good until we were rescued.
“Oh!” I heard a shout.
“Val!” I cried out, immediately jumping into the hole.
I didn’t even think of anyone else as I quickly made my way through. I didn’t have to go far before I broke into another spacing between the rocks. This one was a bit bigger than the last one, and rock overhung it, covering up a bit more of the crack compared to the space. That gave this area a shadowy grotto feel. The ground was grassy, and there was a single tree that was just enough over that it received sunlight. On this tree were a bunch of coconuts. A bit farther down was a dark pool of water.
Val was looking around the place in amazement, when she saw me she let out a giggle. “Isn’t this amazing? It surprised me!”
“It’s okay?” I turned to shout, only to see Cara already coming through.
I reached down to help her up. She took my hand and then didn’t let go of it for a moment. Our eyes met, and her lips parted as if she had several words she wanted to share. It wasn’t until we heard Callie coming out through that the moment broke. She pulled away and turned as well. I made myself scarce, walking over to the pool of what I presumed to be freshwater.
“Coconuts?” Callie asked as she stood up. “That’s food, right?”
“That’s not all.” I declared, tasting the water. “This water comes from some underground source. It’s not saltwater. I believe there are fish in this water too.”
I said this because I had seen a fish break the surface before diving back down. Of course, I had considered fishing to survive. That would have been the most obvious way to avoid starvation. I just had no clue how to do it. We didn’t have any fishing rods or anything. Thankfully, as I came up with a way to fish, we had the coconuts.
“This place is beautiful… and the ground is so soft.” Eve laughed as she came through.
“Plus, it’s got cover from the rain,” Mya added.
The two girls removed their shoes and began running around the grass, giggling. Valerie looked like she wanted to join them, but even though she was younger, she often took her status as an Aunt literally and avoided acting like a child around them. It didn’t matter, as Cara put a stop to it a second later.
“Girls! Stop! We still don’t know if it’s safe. There could be some bug in the grass… or some poisonous plant!”
Cara chastised the girls as they complained.
“It is like Eden. It’s almost too good to be true.” Cassie spoke right next to me.
The other area was just big enough to fit us. This area was nearly the size of a small yard. It had comfortable grass to lie on, enough water to have our fill, and even two types of food once I figured it all out. There was even enough room to get a fire going in the corner. Was that the difference between a blowjob and full penetration? I couldn’t help but let out a sigh of relief. Our ordeal had ended.
Mom struggled to get through, and I had to help her up. After everyone was in and relaxing, I couldn’t help but look up and see the sun rising. We were burning daylight.
“I’m going to try to gather wood so we can get a fire going,” I called out to everyone.
“Find a rock that will open these coconuts too!” Callie cried out, banging one against the wall with a thud.
I nodded, and then crouched down, crawling my way back out the long narrow path until we were outside. As I stood in the clearing in front of the entrance, where the fire I had made had burned out, I shook my head. I was going to need to build a cover for the door. If some wild animal decided to take up residence in that cave while we were in the back area, that’d be a problem. As I crouched down to pick up some wood, I heard a piece of wood crack behind me. I spun around to see Lana standing there. She had followed me back out.
Most of my family was made up of blondes with green or blue eyes. Sally and the twins were redheads, while Cara and my wife had auburn hair. Lana was the oddball, with brown eyes and dark black hair. Where my sisters and I were pretty tall and lanky, Lana was short and curvaceous. She had a large chest and wide hips. This could give her a pudgy appearance, but she kept her weight down and so she instead had a very appealing body.
“Oh, hey. You startled me.” I laughed. “What’s up?”
“She’s not your wife.” Lana declared.
I froze, halfway to grab a stick. “What did you say?”
“Cara is not your wife.”
“I… never said she was.” I tried to play stupid.
“You could have fooled me last night.”
“What do you mean?” I almost winced as I said it.
“Can you not do that?” She asked. “We used to be close friends, remember? We used to be able to say anything to each other. I saw you with Cara last night.”
I closed my eyes and sighed. “That’s between me and Cara.”
“You cheated… so did she!” She declared.
“Are you going to tell anyone?” I tried to defend it.
I felt myself feeling a bit more confident. Yes, I had sex with Cara. She was my brother’s wife and my wife’s sister. We were technically related by marriage twice over. However, she looked like my wife and we weren’t related by blood. As messed up as such a thing is, it’s not something so unbelievable. If I was caught doing anything, this was far more acceptable than some of the other options.
She stared at me for a moment silently. “I just want to know why.”
“Why her?” She asked.
“It’s as you said… she looks like my wife…”
She shook her head. “That’s not it. You don’t have to hide it. I already know.”
She rolled her eyes. “I know about the affair.”
“Okay, I slept with her. I admit it.” I threw up my hands.
A confused expression appeared on her face. “I’m talking about Fara’s affair.”
I blinked. “Her what?”
Lana’s eyes widened and her mouth fell open. “You mean you didn’t know?”
I felt a sudden tinge of anger, and I walked up to Lana and grabbed her arm. “What do you mean, an affair?”
Lana stared at me for a moment, stunned, and then she looked away. “Your wife… has been having an affair on you. I thought you knew. I thought that’s why you slept with her sister, to get back at her.”
“Who is it?” I reached out and grabbed her other arm.
“I wasn’t able to learn that.” She responded.
“Where did you hear it?” I demanded.
“You’re hurting my arm.”
“Where?” I loosened my grip but remained just as insistent.
“It’s not like it’s hard to find out. I just talked to a couple of her friends. If you paid attention to how she spent her free time, it would have been obvious.”
I frowned. “Why have you paid so much attention? Why are you talking to her friends? When I married her, you stopped talking to me!”
She looked up at me, a strange expression on her face, her eyes somewhat met. “I may have stopped talking to you, but I never stopped watching you.”
“Watching?” I sneered. “Don’t you mean stalking?”
“It should have been me.” She shot me a defiant glare.
“What should have been you?” I demanded, a wave of chaotic anger inside me.
“The woman you cheated with!” She shot back. “That’s why I thought you planned this trip! I thought you wanted to reconnect with me!”
“What?” I was genuinely stunned.
“Damn it…” She wiped a tear running down her cheek. “I even planned it. I figured we’d be up drinking one night. We’d both drink a little, and then you’d start complaining about her, and then I told you how I feel, then one thing led to another… I’m so fucking pathetic.”
“Let go.” She tried to pull away from me. “Even when I give my everything, you still would rather give it to that girl.”
“I don’t care! Let go—Mmm!”
Before I realized what I was even doing myself, as she tried to pull away again, I pulled her to me and then kissed her. My tongue went into her mouth, and I roughly kissed my cousin. It lasted for only a moment before she pushed away from me. She looked up at me, a shocked expression on her face. Her entire body shook. Then, without a word, she spun around and ran back into the cave.
“Wait! Lana!” I reached out for her, but Lana disappeared and didn’t return.
I couldn’t help but lift my hand and smack myself on the head. What was I thinking? I had seemingly managed to get away with what I had to do to protect my family. Things were awkward between me and Cara, but at least she was silent. Val also kept her mouth shut. Now, I was kissing Lana. I was just all kinds of messed up.
“Oh, my… you wouldn’t by chance be interested in more gifts, would you?” A familiar voice I didn’t want to hear came from behind.
I turned to tell her to go away, only to be shocked when another question came out of my mouth. “If I fuck Lana, what will I get?”