Concept Stories - NTR Isekai - Part 2

I sat, staring at the magical device in my hands. It was a small pocket mirror. I had accidently put it in my pocket when I wasn’t paying attention and I had never returned it. After finding out about Faith, they hadn’t taken it from me. Perhaps, they didn’t know it had magical properties.

The device was rather simple. It allowed you to hear sounds from a distance away. I realized when you opened it that it could show you an image too. The distance wasn’t far, and you couldn’t look into an area that was completely sealed. However, peaking into a room or spying on someone around the corner was possible.

I wasn’t a spy though, and I couldn’t figure out any way where using this might help me out. I took it and hid it under my bed. After a few moments of thinking, I carefully pulled the drawer out of my nightstand. I then put it in the back behind the drawer and closed it. It was wedged in there so even if someone shook the nightstand, it wouldn’t make a noise.

As I left the room, I ran into the person I wanted to see least of anyone. It was none other than Prince Cole. This was the guy who was spending all of his time with Kate. He had also been the one to condemn Faith to that horrible fate. There had to be some way I could spare her. There had to be something!

“Shouldn’t you be in the store room identifying objects?” The prince asked, his voice sounding snobbish and grating on my ears.

“I know what you’re doing, and it won’t work.” I snapped.

He raised an eyebrow, a small smirk appearing on his face. “Doing? Whatever do you mean?”

“Kate is my girlfriend. We love each other.”

His smile only grew. “Oh? That’s quite cute. You know… in my world, it’s strong who get the women. What strength do you have?”

I took a step forward. “Why don’t you find out?”

“Cole! Cole! I figured it- ah!” It had only been an hour or two since our fight, but seeing Kate run around the corner made me feel like I had been punched in the gut.

She had been calling his name, and she had a glowing smile on her face.

“Kate, you’ve learned the incantation already? You are truly a remarkable woman. Women with your aptitude in magic are extremely valuable for a kingdom.”

Kate blushed. “I-it’s not much… Connor… what are you doing here?”

“It seems he’s shirking his responsibilities. Perhaps he’s hoping all of his classmates can pick up the slack where he is failing.”

“That’s not true!” Realizing I was looking too hostile, I quickly cleared my throat. “I was just asking Riley for some advice.”

“Oh? Is that the girl learning to be a priestess? Yes… the church is quite excited by her presence. Good alchemists are hard to come by.” The prince smiled. “You weren’t saying anything that might cause problems, right?”

“What are you asking?” I demanded.

“Connor!” Kate frowned, shooting me a glare.

“Just that she’ll need to do a lot of studying, and probably has bigger things to worry about than your problems.” He responded flippantly with a shrug. “The initiation only happens twice a year, and it comes in only one week. If she misses it, it’ll be another year before she can join the alchemy guild. They’re very particular about such things.”

“It sounds like Riley does have a lot to worry about.” Kate nodded, accepting his words immediately before shooting me a look. “You probably shouldn’t bother her anymore.”

“You’ll be just as busy.” The prince laughed, tapping her nose in a familiar way that caused her to blush. “Come on, I’ll teach you the next incantation.”

“Another one? Ahhh… my head already hurts.”

“Hah… well, without a little pain, you won’t be able to experience a pleasure.”

“R-really…”

The two walked away, engaged in a conversation almost as if I wasn’t there. I glared at Cole’s back. The pair left, and Kate didn’t even look back at me once. How could she be so cold? It had to be that guy’s influence.

“You!”

I jumped, only to realize Cole had glanced back out into the hall after leading her into a room. “It’s Connor.”

“Heh… like I care about your name.”

“S-sorry?”

“I just wanted to let you know that you really ought to work harder. For example, if you found a device that kept father going, perhaps your cousin wouldn’t need to work so hard to produce.”

My dumbfounded expression turned to fury. “What did you say?”

He shrugged. “It’s your choice, but I’d think you’d want to make things easier on everyone. Any magical device that can do what she does would mean she doesn’t have to do it, right?”

With that, he put his head back into the room. I shook for a minute, realizing that he knew the truth about everything. The prince was an asshole, and he was an asshole who happened to have complete control of me. My first tightened, but he was gone, and even if I attempted to attack him, I wouldn’t get very far. After all, he had the power of magic at his disposal, and I had nothing.

It was an afternoon at this point, half the day gone, but I finally returned to that treasure room. I didn’t know what else to do. Maybe there would be some magical item that could save my classroom. My thoughts went a bit darker. I was looking for a magical item I could use to exact revenge. There had to be some kind of death stick or hero weapon. Once I found it, I would claim it as my own, and then then I would make this kingdom suffer. I just needed to have patience and take my time.

The real problem was that several weapons had formidable power and skills, but they required either talent as a warrior or magical ability as a spellcaster. I didn’t have either, so these items were worthless to me. More than that, these items were things my enemies could use, so whatever I found would have to be even better than that.

I worked through dinner time. I didn’t want to see the prince flirt with my girl, and I didn’t want to hear rumors flying around. Instead, I picked up an item, identified it, and then I wrote it down. I thought about writing a lie. I could tell them it did something else, something that, when they finally tested it out, would lead to their deaths. I needed to find the right item and the right lie.

If I picked any item, then I could be quickly found out. It’d have to be an item where survivability was nonexistent, and thus the chances of me being found out were also nonexistent. Plus, I needed to know who was going to get the item. I didn’t desire to hurt some random person. If there was someone, I wanted dead, it was that despicable commander who had tied me to the chair and forced me to do things with my cousin. It was the line of men who happily banged her person after person.

SNAP!

“Shit!” I hissed.

I had been thinking about the sights from the previous night, and I had ended up clenching the arrow in my hand so tightly that it cracked. Looking around, I quickly straightened it. The wood returned to looking like it wasn’t broken as long as it was held straight. I had felt that it would have burst into flame midflight, so it wasn’t useless. I logged it on the parchment and then I hid it in a pile of other stuff where it couldn’t be easily seen.

With luck, by the time someone found it, I would be long gone. Given the fact this treasure room was dusty, I had probably been the only one that had been in there in some time. It was late at night when I finally left the treasury room and returned to my bed late in the evening. I wish I could say that I couldn’t sleep. I wish I could say that I stayed up all night fretting over where my poor cousin was getting the same treatment that night that she had the previous. However, I was exhausted, and no sooner had my head hit the pillow than I fell asleep.

The next day, I woke up to a knock on the door. I went to cautiously answer it, only opening a crack just to make sure that it wasn’t the princess, intending to find a new situation where she could embarrass or frame me. When I opened the door, I found it was empty. Sitting on the floor was a sealed envelope. I picked it up. There was no address, so I just opened it up.

Dear Connor,

I had a chance to speak to the church about things. They’ve opened my eyes. It goes far deeper than either of us could have imagined. I don’t believe we should talk in person. I’m still digging into things. However, the priesthood may be willing to do something. They said that once I join them, we’ll have the complete support of the church. Isn’t that great? Just keep your head down and stay out of trouble. We’ll figure this out together. I promise.

Sincerely,

Riley

Upon reading her words, I couldn’t help but let out a breath of relief. I hadn’t realized just how tense I had gotten, but her letter had filled me with hope.

“What is that?”

I immediately shoved the letter into my pocket, looking up to see a thorn in my side. The princess approached while I was standing in my doorway. I immediately felt foolish for not closing the door and reading it in private. Riley had gone to such effort to be secretive, yet I had immediately blown all of her efforts.

“Nothing.” I snapped and then added. “Just a note from a friend.”

I prayed that Princess Maria didn’t demand that I hand over the letter. This wasn’t a free country. If a monarch demanded it, it wasn’t wise to refuse. She hadn’t said anything particularly revealing, but it had both our names in it, and it could be misconstrued as us conspiring against the noble family, couldn’t it?

“How has your identification been doing?” She asked, her face just as ice-cold as always. “I didn’t see you at dinner the previous night. I inquired about you but no one knew where you were.”

It was just great. Now, the princess was asking after my well-being, selling that lie.

“It’s doing fine,” I responded showing my teeth. “I worked late into the night to do my part.”

Those words sounded like shit on my tongue, but I knew it wouldn’t hurt to flatter them and seem like a team player. After all, Riley had advised me to play along. Well, I could act the part just as they did.

“I see… however, you must come to dinner tonight.” She responded. “It is an order. I won’t have you getting weak from lack of nourishment.”

“How is that your business?” I wasn’t able to hold back my scorn earlier.

There was a door thud down the hallway, and suddenly the princess jumped forward pushing me into my room. As soon as she was inside, she turned and closed the door. She remained like that with her hands on the door, her back to me.

“What is that?” I asked.

“Shh!” She hissed.

My emotions tumbled in confusion. What was going on? The princess was suddenly acting extremely odd. That was when I realized that I had her alone.

“Yesterday, you lied to Kate about us. Why?” I grabbed her arm

She looked back at her arm, and then at me. “I did no such thing.”

“Yes, you did.”

“What lie did I tell?” She asked.

“You said that we were together, and then you thanked me for a good time!” I snapped back.

“We were together, and if you do not wish to be thanked for your time, then I won’t.”

“That’s not how it was-” There was a knocking on my door causing me to stop in mid-sentence.

“Connor? It’s Kate.” A voice came through. “Are you there?”

What were the chances that Kate would come by again just as the princess was there? No, was that why she had pushed her way into my room? Did she hear Kate coming and decide to set me up again? I saw her opening her mouth to answer, and in desperation, I reached out a grabbed her, covering her mouth. Her eyes widened, but she said nothing.

“I’m here! I am… oh, but I’m in the middle of bathing!” I closed my eyes shut.

“R-really… I heard voices, were you in there with someone else?”

Why did I have to say that? Now, if I said the princess was present, it’d be even more suspicious. I wasn’t guilty of anything. Damn it, this was awful.

“Ah… no… I’m here alone. It’s just me. What did you want?”

The princess crossed her arms, but she otherwise didn’t react to me keeping her mouth covered. There was a brief silence.

“Connor… I came to apologize about yesterday. It’s just… the stress of the new world. I’m finding out all about this new power in my body. I didn’t mean to snap. I was hoping you could join me for breakfast?”

“Ye-yeah… I would love to. J-just go on without me. I’ll be there. Just need to finish up.” There was another long silence.

“O-okay… I love you.”

“You too.” I bit my lip.

“I remained holding the princess until I could hear her steps walking away. Finally, I let go of her and let out a breath.

She straightened her clothing and sniffed. “Well, if one of us is a liar, we know which one.”

“I wouldn’t have to lie if you didn’t push me in here. Why are you trying to ruin my relationship with my girlfriend?” I demanded.

“I don’t know, maybe I’m just jealous!” She shot back, her cold exterior twisting for a second.

Those words stunned me so much that I didn’t have an answer to respond. She sniffed, turning her back and opening the door. As soon as it was open, I could see Kate standing there. She hadn’t let at all but had remained to wait. When her eyes landed on the Princess, she nodded, tears forming in her eyes.

“A simple sound spell…” Kate spoke quietly.

“I told him to be honest about us, but he chose to lie instead.” The princess responded and then straightened herself, turned, and walked away.

As she put it, she hadn’t said a single lie, but the way she said it was misleading. Worse of all, I had fallen right into it again.

“It’s not what it looks like.” I lifted my hands.

“Then… what does it look like?” Kate asked.

“They’re trying to get between us,” I explained. “The prince thinks you’re too good for me. He’s working with the princess. It’s more than that, though. This whole place is rotten. Please, you need to listen to me.”

“I… want to listen.” She said hesitantly.

At that moment, there was the sound of armor clanking. She turned, her eyes widening at something going on down the hallway. I stepped out to see a group of five guards quickly moving up. I grabbed Kate to pull her to the side, but then the guards stopped right in front of us.

“Are you Connor?” One of the men asked.

“Yes?”

“Then you’re under arrest.”

I blinked, fearing for a second that they found the mirror I stole. “Why?”

“Destruction of palace property!” He held out the arrow broken in two.

My mouth fell open and then closed. I had even expected them to find that, yet they had found it faster than I could have believed. Before I knew what was happening, I was already taken down to the dungeon and thrown inside. Although I had been on field trips and seen dungeons before, they weren’t actively being used, and the walkthroughs couldn’t even begin to prepare me for the reality I was forced to endure.

It was incredibly dark, and the smell was horrendous. The waste of decaying and half-dead humans mixed with mold, mildew, and feces. The floor was wet and muddy, and I could only hope that what I was sitting in was mud. Even the sounds were horrendous, a continuous whistling noise of wind escaping through some cracks, and the occasional moan and cry of some lost soul who had been left to rot. I had only been in there an hour before the cold started to seep into my bones, and I started to realize that if hell had a temperature, it wouldn’t be hot, but something more like this.

“Several classmates have already appealed to your case.” My teacher spoke quietly, adjusting her glasses.

It had been a night that I had sat in the dark, holding my knees and shivering. It had been the longest night of my life, and every time I tried to sleep, I felt a rodent biting at my toes and ended up jerking awake. I stayed up the entire night and felt impossibly tired. Just when I thought this hell would never end, a light had come in the darkness, and that light was none other than my teacher. As soon as she arrived, I felt a sense of calmness wash over me. Ms. Diane was here to free me. That’s what I thought, but when she spoke, there was a tinge of regret in her eyes.

“How can they do this?” I asked, knowing my voice had a tinge of a whimper and sounded far more pathetic than I had intended.

“This is a foreign place.” Ms. Diane let out a sigh. “We have to follow their rules and customs while living here. That artifact had a great deal of value. Had you admitted it at the time, they might have gone easier on you, but damaging something from the royal vault is akin to attacking the kingdom itself. That’s why this is so serious.”

“I can’t believe this…” I lowered my head in despair. “No, they’re just doing this to hide what they did to my cousin!”

I had only told Riley about what had happened. I was so embarrassed about what I had done, that I had been threatened to keep my mouth shut, but it just occurred to me that I was already in prison. Things couldn’t get much worse for me. My only option was to try to explain everything to Ms. Diane. She was our teacher, after all, and she should be able to do something to protect her. At the very least, I’d have another person working on the outside.

“What about your cousin?” Ms. Diana asked. “Now that I think about it, I haven’t seen her in a few days.

“Faith, she…”

“What about me?” A voice sounded out, causing both of us to turn.

From the darkness of the hallway, a familiar girl came walking out. It was Faith. She was wearing a simple dress from this world and a pair of leather shoes. Her hair was combed, and her makeup was done. A small smile formed on her lips as she looked at me.

“Faith!” I cried out, my mouth opening and closing a few times.

“Hello, cus.” She giggled.

Ms. Diane looked back and forth between Faith and me, her eyebrow raised. “Is there something the matter?”

“The guards…” I began but found my voice getting caught under Faith’s eye. “She… Faith?”

I realized I couldn’t get it out. She was standing right in front of me now, and all of my energy seemed to drain out like a plug had been pulled.

“It’s fine, cousin. You look like you’ve seen a ghost.” Faith smiled awkwardly.

“Are you doing alright?” Ms. Diana asked, still looking between us consideringly.

“I’m doing great!” Faith smiled. “The guards found a way to make my powers useful. That’s why I’ve been so busy. I’ve out training hard.”

“Oh? Is that so?”

I shook my head slightly. “You don’t have to lie… don’t protect me. Tell the truth! Tell her about what happened. About how they…”

Damn it! It kept getting caught in my throat. I was still a coward. I couldn’t just say it.

“Cousin!” She let out a laugh. “They were a bit rough at first, but that was just part of the training. That’s all it was. We all have to work hard. There are no free tickets.”

Ms. Diane looked her up and down suspiciously. “Are you sure? There is nothing wrong?”

“Of course!” Faith laughed. “You see how much the guys training with the soldiers get hurt. My Cousin just saw me getting overworked and overreacted. However, for him to try to punish them by breaking things, that’s a big no-no!”

She wagged a finger at me teasingly, and I stared at her in disbelief. I knew my cousin. I had grown up with her. My cousin could be teasing a bit, but she was never like this. She used to look at me lovingly, but now when her eyes met mine, I felt nothing. It was like there was nothing there behind her eyes anymore.

Ms. Diane let out a sigh. “So, that is what happened. Connor, in the future, you can’t let your childish feelings affect your judgment. This is a world where you’re considered an adult at 13. In my eyes, you may still be my children, but this world sees you all as adults capable of your own decisions. Don’t forget it from now on.”

“That’s not-” I was shaking my head as Ms. Diane seemed to come to her conclusions.

“Don’t worry! I think we’re all growing up very quickly here.” Faith cut in. “I’ll make sure Connor man’s up too.”

Ms. Diane nodded, looking my way once before her lips tightened. “I’m going to check on your release status. I’ll see if I can’t leverage some of the student’s powers to facilitate your release.”

Before I could say anything more, Ms. Diane turned her back on me and started to walk away. Faith remained behind, though, a small smile still on her lips. When Ms. Diane was out of earshot, I leaned toward Faith.

“What are you doing? Why didn’t you tell her the truth?” I demanded in a hushed voice.

“Tell her what?” Faith asked, cocking her head and touching her cheek cutely. “That cousin couldn’t control himself and had to taste his relative?”

“You! That’s not what happened!”

“Hmm? Are you sure that’s not what happened? Connor got so excited watching me work, he couldn’t help but join in.”

“No!” I cried out. “They forced you… they forced me. Look, they freed you now. You have a chance to escape.”

She shrugged. “I got a message from Riley worrying about me, so I had to show my face. Everyone has been super nice, but I’m feeling a bit itchy.”

“Itchy?” I asked.

“Mmm… I haven’t had a cock in me in a few hours.” As she spoke, she lifted her skirt revealing she wasn’t wearing underwear. “It’s making me wet.”

Her pussy was completely shaved and on full display. It was engorged and red, and there was even some stuff leaking out of it. There was writing on her inner thighs and abdomen in this world’s language. We all got the ability to read this world’s language when we were summoned, so I could see the words ‘whore’, ‘slut’, and ‘insert dick here’ with an arrow pointing at her slit.

My entire body shook. For a second, I was hoping that perhaps I was just going insane, but this confirmed everything that had happened was real. It had become the entire barracks cumdumpster for three days now while I had done nothing. I couldn’t feel anything but guilt.

“I’m sorry…”

“Why is cousin sad?” She asked, her expression looking genuinely confused. “I’m an onihole, the kingdom’s cumdumpster. The prince gave me that official position after using me.”

“Even the prince used you?” I made a face.

I knew it was a small thing, but I had already hated that man. He was working his magic on my girlfriend, but he was still banging my cousin on the side. He was a piece of shit!

“Ah… it was nice.” She sighed and then looked down. “Oh, it looks like cousin is getting excited and wants another round?”

“What?” I followed her eyes, and to my shock, my penis was erect.

I was surprised that I felt excited because my mind was anywhere but sex right now. Rather than feeling horny, I was wracked with guilt and regret.

She pursed her lips for a second and then giggled. “Well, if cousin wants me, he can have me. I’m horny, so please use my holes. You can pick whichever one you want.”

I shook my head. “I’m not going to do that!”

“Are you suuureee…” She spoke in a drawn-out voice, and to my horror she bent over, pushing her butt right against my bars. “My pussy needs it so bad.”

As she rubbed her butt against the bars, they pushed her buns to the side, spreading her open and revealing her cunt and butthole on full display. I swallowed, realizing my mouth was watering. What was coming over me? I was feeling extremely tempted to stick it in through the bars. I felt like that time before…

“The pheromones!”

“Now that I started making them, I can seem to stop.” She spoke in a pouty voice. “But that’s a good thing since it makes everyone aroused. Kate was so cute. The prince invited us both to lunch and by the end she was squirming in her seat, eyeing him with such desire. I thought she’d mount him right there…. Ahhh!”

I had leaped up and reached through the bars, grabbing onto her sides. “What did you say? Is she fucking him?”

Faith was breathing hard, pressing her ass back against the bars even as she leaned into me. “I don’t know. I left and came down here shortly after. For all I know, she’s riding his cock right now. She – kek…”

“You!” I realized one of my hands was tightened around her throat, while the other slid down between her legs, rubbing her clit.

I loosened my grip on her neck and she purred. “Don’t think about her, cus. I want your dick in me. Fuck me, Daddy. Fuck your cousin. Ahhhn!”

She hadn’t even finished the words before my dick was shoving into her. Although she was on one side of the bars and I was on the other, I was plowing into her from behind through the bars. Her pussy was warm and tight, and it felt like heaven, especially after the dank cold and fright. I was angry, frustrated, and lonely, and despite my best efforts, this appeared to be the only thing that I could outlet all of my frustration on.

A tear fell down my cheek, but I continued to roughly fuck my cousin, one hand fingering her clit while the other choked her. I was angry that I was in jail. I was afraid that my cousin seemed to have lost her wits. I was upset that my girlfriend was with that bastard. I was frustrated that no one seemed to believe me. And so, I thrust my frustrations out into my cousin’s waiting twat.

“Ahh! Yeah! That’s it!” She squealed as I kept pounding into her pussy. “You’re gonna make me cum like a little slut!”

I grunted. “Shut up.”

She moaned. “Make me cum! Make me cum for you!”

As I continued to pound her and she goaded me on, I found my anger melting away. This was an opportunity to vent my frustrations, and she was taking them all. My cock throbbed within her tight pussy and I growled.

“Let me hear you say it again,” I whispered in her ear.

Her body quivered with each thrust, and she began to gyrate her hips back against me. “Yes! Yes! Oh god yes! Fuck me, Daddy! Let me hear you say it! Cum inside me! Fill me with your cum!”

I thrust harder and harder into her, grunting. “Fuck! I don’t fucking care!”

“Oh god! Yes! Please! Cum in me! I need it! Need your cum!” She begged erotically.

“Fuuuuck!” I cried, letting go of her neck and yanking her hair, pulling her head back against the bars. “Cum for me, you whore!”

I was pulling her hair painfully through the bars while thrusting into her like an animal. Even if I wanted to stop at that moment, I was no longer able.

She screamed. “Ah! Ah! Aah! Fuck! Fuck! Ahhhhh!”

And then, just as I thought I would cum myself, she orgasmed. I felt her pussy spasm around my shaft and heard her scream. I pounded her hard, pushing my hands onto the metal bars over her head. I pulled her hair back, keeping her head pinned in between the bars. Her body was nearly stuck in between. Her mouth hung open as she drooled, tears of joy running down her cheeks. I kept my hips pinned between the bars and pounded her mercilessly until my climax overtook me.

“Ah! Ah! Ah! Ugh! Ohhh! Fuck! AHHHHHHH! FUCK!” I bucked my hips repeatedly, emptying my load into her hot pussy.

Her legs shook as I continued to pound her, holding her trapped between the bars, her knees bent, and her arms hanging limply at her sides. Finally, I collapsed, panting.

After a few moments of silence, she let out a small whimper and slowly moved her body away from mine. When she turned to look at me, her eyes were filled with regret.

For a moment, I thought that she had come to her senses, and realizing what I had done, I felt like a monster again. Yet her, next words made me feel cold.

“Was that all you had?” She asked, looking down at my softening member. “I barely even cummed once and you’ve already spent? I’m sorry cousin, your cock isn’t enough for me anymore.”

She seemed more resigned than anything.

“Faith…”

“I’m going to go find more cock and work hard for the kingdom. Cousin, you work hard too, and don’t cause any more trouble, okay?”

I opened my mouth but then closed it again. She let her dress fall back down, stuck her tongue out at me playfully, and then skipped back down the hallway. She seemed completely unconcerned about what we had just done, or that I was still in prison. I felt cold once again, and even more alone than before. The respite from fucking her went away all too quickly. However, the sleep I had been waiting for finally reached me. I collapsed into the mud and wrapped myself in a fetal position as I passed out.

My nightmares were filled with dreams of Kate being violated by Prince Cole, although the waking world felt no better.

___

I spent another cold night in the prison. This time, I wasn’t able to stay on my feet and ended up collapsing in the muck. Although there was a myriad of nasty smells, the one that assaulted my nose the most was the smell of Faith’s wet pussy. I naturally couldn’t wash my hand or my cock, and so they both smelled like her erotic body. It left me hard and feeling like I might break at any second. Worst of all, whenever I could manage to sleep, I awoke to the painful bites of rats.

I wasn’t sure how much time passed by after that, but I knew I was starving. It was to the point where the rats themselves were starting to sound tasty. I considered pretending to sleep to draw one out and then grabbing it before they scattered so that I could eat something. My stomach felt as hollow as my soul.

That’s when the door opened with light one more time. I raised my hand shakily as a short bald man in a robe walked in. Beside him were two guards. I watched as they approached and then stopped in front of my cage. I looked at them hopefully.

“This is the guy.” The man declared. “Free him.”

I could only stare blankly as the two men unlocked the door. A moment later, they entered my cage and undid the shackles. I was still staring blankly.

“F-free…”

The bald man smiled gently. “Yes, all crimes have been dropped. You will have to thank your friend thoroughly for this.”

“M-my friend?” I blinked. “Ms. Diane?”

The man didn’t say more, gesturing to the guards who helped me stand. As they pulled me out of the dungeon, the light was extremely bright. The next few hours became a bit blurry. I knew I was given a warm bath. I was able to clean off the gunk all over me and warm myself from the chill that had seemingly sunk deeply into my body.

When the bath was finished, a servant brought a spread of food. I quickly got dressed into a simple commoner’s garb. As I did so, I looked in the mirror and barely noticed myself anymore. My skin was pale, and my hair looked a bit greasy. My eyes were sunken and my toned body now looked a bit too skinny. I wouldn’t say I was ugly, but the handsome aura I once gave off was long gone.

The smell of the food sitting nearby hit my nose and my stomach growled. I couldn’t hold back any longer, sitting down and immediately consuming it all. It was simpler food than the nobles typically ate, but for me who hadn’t eaten in what felt like days, it was delicious. I aggressively ate it like I was afraid I’d never be able to eat again.

“You should eat slower. If you shove it in your mouth, it will make you sick.” A voice sounded out.

I looked up, and couldn’t help but gasp at the sight of Riley. She was wearing the simple robes of the church, but she looked very beautiful. It was hard to say what was different about her. Her hair was a bit wavier and fuller. Her skin was white and free of blemishes. Her lips looked a bit deeper red, and her eyes were more piercing. It was like all of the damage I had taken the last few days, making me pale, scrawny, and sunken, had happened in reverse to her.

“You’re beautiful,” I said before I could stop myself.

Riley blushed, her beauty even becoming more enhanced. “The church takes good care of me. They get first pick over many of the alchemic potions made. They insist I use a variety of products. They are magical. There is a saying in this world that women of the church never age, and after seeing their beauty products that defy logic, I believe it. Many of the other girls are jealous. Some of them have even tried to flirt with the priests as if they weren’t celibate!”

She let out a long giggle, seemingly carefree as she sat on the chair across from me. I forced myself to finish what I was eating and swallow before turning to her.

“You sent me a note earlier. Are you the one who helped me?”

Riley bit her lip and nodded. “I had to agree to become a priestess to get the church to intervene.”

“A priestess? Is that… like…”

“It’s for life.” She lowered her head. “Originally, I was only working with the church to learn alchemy, but they’ve revealed a bit about the nobility here.”

“What about?” I asked, trying to look uninterested, even though the legitimacy of the nobility was a subject of great interest to me.

“The items to do alchemy are extremely difficult to obtain.” She explained. “A normal person isn’t able to obtain them at a market, which means that someone who wants to do alchemy has to have special connections.”

“Like the nobles?”

“Yes, nobles want to rope an alchemist in, but doing so ties your fate to that noble. You’re left with whatever recipes nobility can get their hands on. You might live a little better, but your life belongs to that noble, and your ability to grow is almost nothing. You’ll spend most days manufacturing the same potions over and over again which the nobles will trade for the potions they want. Most alchemists opt to join the priesthood instead.”

“Is the priesthood better?” I asked uncertainly.

“Oh, yes, much better.” She declared enthusiastically. “They have a library of potion recipes. They’ve allowed me to access a few of the simple ones, but the ones I’ve been using on my skin, as well as most of their best, are kept under lock and key. Only by joining them will they allow you to study these potion recipes. You also gain the right to use them at will. Of course, there is a point system, so you have to sell potions to the church to earn points to buy ingredients and recipes, but it’s all fair, and the church sells those potions to the public and nobles, so we’re doing a service as well but on our terms.”

“You’d think they’d worry about someone running off with the recipe.” I contemplated.

She shook her head. “They use a magical contract. There is something called the purification ceremony, and once the initiate’s body and soul are clean, they become a permanent member of the church.”

I frowned. “This sounds serious. If you become a priestess… didn’t you mention something about celibacy?”

She gave a half smile. “You caught that, huh? I had to do this for you, you know?”

I lifted my hands. “I didn’t mean to, I mean, I’m sorry!”

She let out a little giggle and then leaned across the table. “Do you want to hear something?”

I blinked. “What?”

“To join the priesthood, I have to take a vow of celibacy.” She explained. “However, that doesn’t speak to what I do before then. I carefully talked to several priests, and many of them weren’t virgins before joining.”

I raised an eyebrow. “What are you trying to say?”

Her face turned slightly pink. “The ceremony is in one week. That means I have one week before I have to commit to my life as a priestess.”

I thought about her words for a few moments, and then I gasped. “You’re not saying…”

“Yes,” She looked around nervously like she was afraid someone was looking at her. “I think I’m ready. If I can only have it one time, I want to do it with you.”

We talked for a little bit longer. I told her about Faith, although I didn’t mention the part about us having sex. I merely warned Riley that Faith was likely brainwashed and couldn’t be trusted.

“I’m not sure Kate can be trusted either. Prince Cole… I think he’s gotten in her head.” I hesitantly gave that warning at the end.

I was worried I’d lose Riley’s trust by blaming the other girls too much, be she merely nodded. “You’ve suffered a lot, Connor.”

For a second, I felt choked up. After suffering from all of this, I finally had someone on my side. Riley wasn’t just my friend, but we were about to make it official too. I knew that she was going to become a priestess, but we could figure that out. I’m sure that once Riley tasted it once, she wouldn’t be against repeats. What the priests didn’t know wouldn’t hurt them.

“Is there anything else I can do? For the church, I mean.” I asked uncertainly.

If we were talking about bringing the church down, then I wanted to help. Nothing would make me happier than seeing Prince Cole lose everything. Then, there was that bitch Princess Maria. I would tie her up and then fuck her in every hole until she was just an onahole, then give her to her troops. I’d let her experience what they did to my cousin!

“You just need to have patience,” Riley spoke quietly. “The church believes that the nobility has been corrupt for some time. However, they still don’t have enough power where they can just take over. Even if there was proof, they still have an army. Just keep your head low. If anything comes your way, pass it to me, and let me know before you do anything foolish!”

“I-I will!”

Riley finally nodded, satisfied by my promise. She finally parted after making sure I had eaten enough. She told me that the church had cut a deal with the kingdom. The church had given the kingdom potions equaling the value of the magic item I destroyed. With the debt squared away, my crime was wiped out. It was as if nothing ever happened. In other words, I could return to my room.

Once Riley had left, I finished everything left on the plate. I poked the empty dishes a few times as if I could magically cause more to appear from them, but when that didn’t happen, I could only sigh and get up. I left the room, and it didn’t take long before I was walking through familiar hallways.

“Connor!” I heard a yell and turned to see Willow.

“Willow!” I smiled, holding out my arms.

She ran down the hallway and threw her arms around me. The force of her body striking mine very nearly threw me on my back. I was a bit shocked. Willow’s arms were thicker now, and she had a lot of strength in them. I felt like I was being bear-hugged. As soon as she noticed my struggle, she let go with a blush.

“S-sorry!” She cried out. “I didn’t realize my strength!”

After days of being in a cell, my body was weaker than I had ever been. Meanwhile, Willow had been training nonstop. Even there, she was wearing training armor. She was in the best shape of her life. At some point, the power dynamic between the two of us had shifted, and she was now the stronger one between us. I didn’t know how I felt about that, but I wasn’t going to make Willow feel bad. I smiled at her approvingly.

“You’re doing good with your training.” I gave her encouragement.

“It has been tough. Every day has just been swinging a sword until I collapse unconscious and then get up to swing again. I didn’t even hear you were in jail until last night.” Willow’s beaming smile slipped slightly. “Are you okay?”

“Yeah,” I reassured her, showing her my body. “It was just a misunderstanding. It’s resolved now.”

Seeing Willow’s smiling face, I didn’t have it in me to tell her all of my problems. Willow had always been a bit simple-minded, and she wouldn’t be able to keep a secret like Riley. She would assuredly worry about it, possibly talking to her trainers, who would then pass the word on to the nobles. At that moment, it was better to just see her be happy and carefree.

Upon hearing my words, she relaxed a bit, giving me a beaming smile. “You just wanted me to worry. You’re lucky you got out today.”

“Why’s that?” I asked.

“We’re going on an expedition that will take two weeks. I would have been worrying about you the entire time.” She explained. “There is a small goblin outpost and the soldiers need to go clear it out.”

I frowned. “Is that safe?”

“We’re training to be warriors.” She made a face. “Of course, it’s not safe.”

“But, are you ready? Isn’t it a bit too soon? You could get hurt?”

She took a step back, her smile slipping. “I’m not a complete newbie. I already had a talent for it and my mentor taught us well. Besides, the experts will be there right alongside us the entire time. Don’t you trust me?”

Seeing her originally happy expression sink as I questioned her, I realized I needed to put my doubts behind me. I quickly swallowed them and then smiled at her.

“No, of course, you’ll be great. I just love you and will miss you.”

She blushed, her good humor returning with a bit of shyness. “I missed you too.”

I started to feel a bit excited. Before the transmigration, my relationship with Willow had only recently become open and accepted by my girlfriend. We had been doing it almost every day. Then, we came here and hadn’t touched each other in over a week. It seemed like Willow was having the same idea as me.

“Want to go to my room?” I asked, looking her up and down and thinking she looked pretty sexy in armor.

She had lost weight and gained muscle. She looked much fitter than she had before, and I already found myself wanting to see her toned naked body. She looked at me with desire and temptation.

Biting her lip, she regretfully shook her head. “Not now. I have to head back. I just saw you while I was returning to practice from lunch. I’m already late and will probably be chastised.”

“Oh…” I lowered my head, feeling regret once again.

She leaned forward. “Tonight.”

“Tonight?”

“Come to my room tonight. We can do things then. I promise.”

My eyes lite up. “It’s a promise.”

Willow smiled at me. After everything that I had experienced since coming to this world, that glowing smile was like a dehydrated many getting a glass of water in the desert. I drank it to my fullest, and after she turned the corner, I couldn’t help but laugh.

“What are you laughing about?” My good humor immediately hit a brick wall as I heard a voice I didn’t want to hear.

Spinning around, the princess was standing there once again. She had the same cool, emotionless expression on her face that she always had. Every time she had shown up, it had seemingly been shortly before Kate. Was I just randomly going to be running into everyone? I wanted to meet the princess with hatred and scorn, but I had just been imagining all the things I would do to torture her. She was a beautiful girl, after all, and I was backed up. This awkward situation put me in a strange mindset where I immediately imagined her naked and folded up into various positions.

“What do you want?” I demanded to keep myself from staring, yet unable to keep the strain from entering my voice.

“You were in prison.” She took a step forward, raising her hand.

I took several steps back, eyeing her as I turned away, trying to hide an unwanted erection. “Yeah… a lot good you did to help.”

She cocked her head, her eyes flickering to my pants so quickly that if I hadn’t been looking for it, I wouldn’t have noticed. “I requested Father release you. I gave a formal protest.”

I sneered, not believing her words a single bit. “Well, it was the church who ended up helping in the end. Willow helped me.”

“The church is… not to be trusted.” She spoke, looking a bit uncertain.

I almost spit hearing her words. She couldn’t be trusted. I had such little trust in her that her telling me not to trust the church only made me trust them more. I just wished my dick would pay attention!

“Oh? Why is that?” I asked.

“They are full of conspiracies and plans. Not all of their plans align with the throne.” She responded with a shrug. “The church only cares about the church, and there is always a cost in dealing with them.”

For a moment, I thought about how Willow had to become a priestess to get the church to intervene on my behalf, but then I shook my head. Maria did not have my best interest at heart. That was already abundantly clear.

“Excuse me, I have to go to work now.” I declared, turning away from her.

“Wait!” She cried out.

Every part of me wanted to run, but for some reason, my legs stopped as if I lost control of them. I stood there for a few seconds.

“What?” I asked through gritted teeth.

“The next time you’re in trouble…” Princess Maria spoke lightly. “You can come to me. I will… take care of your problem.”

Had her words been spoken by another, I would have thought she was flirting with me. There seemed to be undertones of seductiveness, but it was all mixed with her emotionless way of speaking. I shuddered slightly.

“I’ll take that into advisement.” I managed to free my legs and escape the situation.

When I turned the corner, I regained my breath. I hadn’t embarrassed myself in front of Kate or done anything else that would cause me trouble. Furthermore, my dick was finally soft again. I had never been the kind of who took care of it myself. Almost since I was able to get hard, I had a girl in my life willing to satisfy it. I shook my head. It didn’t matter. I would finally get some relief tonight. Willow had my back.

Thinking about all the things I was going to do with Willow, my dick returned, but I managed to get to the treasure room without any awkward encounters. The guards let me into it, and I could see it was the same as I left it. There was no sign anyone else had been there or moved anything. I even looked for the arrow I had broken, and it was the only thing missing.

A bit of fear and discomfort weighed on me. Was I being watched? They must have some means of surveillance. At the time, I had been happy they were giving me so much trust. I could have stolen or walked away with any number of magical items. This was how they kept me honest. Yet, I was never questioned about the magic item I had left in my pocket. Was it the act of destroying the item that alerted them?

I didn’t understand enough. I decided I had no choice but to lay low. Riley and the church would ultimately have my back. The fact that the Princess warned me against them only made me more willing to listen to them. I did my job, taking the care necessary that not another single magic item was damaged. Although I had already decided I hated the nobles, I took solace in knowing their days would be numbered.

Besides, the dungeon had left a fair amount of trauma deep within my soul. Every time I remembered that dark basement with the rats and the horrifying smells, I shivered a bit. I couldn’t give them any reason to put me back down there until I came up with a surefire way to obtain my revenge. I became so lost in my work and my thoughts of vengeance that it had grown late and I hadn’t even realized it.

“Ah, shit!” I cursed as I realized I had missed dinner, and the time I had agreed to meet with Willow was almost there.

I finished up and left the room, immediately racing for my room. I ran inside, glad to see it was empty of any unwanted intrusion. I grabbed the mirror. I didn’t want to be caught with it, but I also didn’t feel confident making it to Willow’s room. The boys and girls had been placed on different wings. It wasn’t like the boys couldn’t visit the girls or the girls visit the boys, but after everything that had happened, I didn’t want to be caught on the girl’s side, especially this late at night.

After very quickly washing myself, I left the room with the mirror in hand. I naturally made sure that the Princess and Prince couldn’t sneak up on me again, but I also watched for guards or anyone else that might get in my way. I headed over to the girl’s wing. By that point, it was already past the time I was supposed to be there, but I wasn’t going to skip our promised meeting time. A door opened, and I quickly hid behind a pedestal that had an expensive vase on it.

The room felt familiar, and I used the mirror to observe it. When I saw the person, my heart immediately fell a bit. It was Kate. She looked both ways as if she was sneaking, and then started walking quietly away. As she turned a corner, I left my pedestal with a frown on my face. I only just saw the last bits of her hair before she turned a corner. I didn’t know the exact time in this world, but it was probably the equivalent of 11 at night. Where would Kate be heading this late at night? She wasn’t heading in the direction of my room.

Part of me wanted to follow after her, but my hormones won out. Kate could do whatever she wanted. I still had Willow who was willing and wanted me. Feeling a bit of rage toward Kate, I decided I’d vindicate all of my desires on Willow. I snuck up to her room and then lightly knocked.

“I-it’s me,” I whispered.

There was a long quiet, and then the door softly click unlock and opened. I looked in to see Willow there. She grabbed me and pulled me inside before closing the door and locking it. I was barely a step into the room before we were kissing passionately. I felt wonderful feeling a girl pressed against me again. I didn’t count those events with my cousin. This was exactly what I was missing, the intimacy with a girl.

“You’re late!” She let out a hot breath as I sucked on her neck.

“I’m sorry,” I responded, eagerly pulling at her clothing.

“Don’t worry about it, you’re here now.” She growled, grabbing me.

“Ah!” I let out a cry as she picked me up and tossed me on the bed. “What the hell?”

She laughed as she jumped on top of me. “I’m a lot stronger now. See?”

She pulled off her shirt, and for the first time, I could see how her training was progressing. His skin had tightened up, and her arms were smooth and muscular. Although she didn’t have six-pack abs, her once pudge midsection was completely smooth. She also seemed to exude a perkiness an energy that she never had before.

“You’re amazing.” I smiled, feeling all of my worries disappear, if only for a brief time.

“I want your dick inside me!” She purred, immediately fishing in my pants.

“E-easy!” I cried out.

“Kay…” She said in a sing-song voice, but ultimately she still got my dick out in her hands.

Her fingers were warm to the touch, and they started playing with it. I leaned back and moaned. As I felt the pleasure though, the memory of Faith came flooding home. I remembered her defilement as well as me doing her even while I was filthy in prison. That had only been the previous night, and I had not addressed that trauma.

“Ahhh…” I groaned.

“Hmm? What’s wrong?” She played with my dick some more, but it remained soft. “Are you doing okay?”

No! I wasn’t going to let those bad memories ruin my time with Willow. I grabbed Willow and spun around, putting her on the bed.

“Eiii!” She cried out this time.

“Hehe, I’m fine!” I joked, leaning in and kissing her.

To buy myself some more time, I used foreplay. I kissed her face and then her neck. Slowly, I worked my way down. I spent a little time on her breasts, but not so much that I seemed like some dudebro who just wanted to play with boobs. I kissed her stomach and then skipped right to her thighs. It was only at the end that I targeted her labia. I was doing a good job. She was panting and moaning, and I could see her pussy glisten with desire. I barely touched her with my tongue though when I heard loud banging on the door.

The sound unhinged me and I nearly fell off the edge of the bed. Willow jerked up, cursing under her breath.

“Who-” I was going to ask who was bothering her this late at night, but she immediately shushed me.

“Quick, hide under the bed.” She hissed.

I opened my mouth to argue, but she was already grabbing me and forcing me under. I was shocked at how strong Willow had gotten. I had no choice but to get under the bed under her control. She quickly put her clothing back on. She straightened herself, took a glance in the mirror, and then opened the door where the person was banging again. The door burst open as soon as she unlatched it and a man strode in. Willow stumbled back and to the side, a surprised look on her face.

“Are you okay?” He demanded, grabbing the hilt of his sword.

“I-I’m fine!” Willow protested, her face red. “Wh-what are you doing here, sir?”

He looked around a little. His eyes had a deadly fierceness to them. Unlike me, he did have a six-pack. His body was very fit, and it showed even through his leather armor. His eyes passed over the bed but thankfully didn’t lock on me. I still couldn’t help but shiver. After a glance around the room, he finally relaxed, sheathing his sword.

“I heard a noise complaint. Someone thought you might be in trouble.” He explained.

“I’m fine, sir.” She couldn’t help but turn red. “I was just… working out!”

He looked at her, red and sweaty, and sighed. “I know you wish to succeed, but you shouldn’t hurt yourself trying. It’s important to take adequate rest at night. You’re already the best recruit of all your classmates.”

“I-I’ll keep that in mind, sir.”

He made a face. “Did I not tell you to call me Benjamin when we’re not in uniform.”

“B-but, you are in uniform!” She protested.

He looked down at his outfit and then let out a laugh. “Oh, yeah, I am. Oh, that reminds me of why I even came here. I was looking for your already.”

“You were?” Willow asked inquisitively.

“New orders. We’re leaving before daybreak, so you need to start packing now.”

“Now?” Willow gasped. “What happened to leave tomorrow?”

“There was new intel on the goblins. We need to move now or risk them attacking a nearby village. There are women and children there…”

Willow’s expression turned serious and she shook her head. “You don’t need to explain. I’ll be right there.”

“Good.” He nodded, standing straight.

A few seconds later, she makes a wooden smile. “I need to change.”

“Of course.” He nodded, but as she continued to stare at him, he let out a cough. “Oh, right! Of course. I’m sorry, I’m used to men… I’ll be right outside. Call me if you need anything.”

He left the room awkwardly, and only once the door was closed did she spin around and lean against it, letting out a breath. I finally used the opportunity to slide out from under her bed.

“What’s going on?” I demanded in a whisper. “You’re leaving?”

“It looks like that’s the order. I’ll be gone for two weeks…”

“When you said you were leaving, I thought we had time!” I snapped. “Not tomorrow!”

“I’m sorry.” She bit her lip. “I only learned we were leaving today. I was going to tell you after we… well, it doesn’t matter now.”

“Willow…” I reached out and grabbed her, moving to kiss her mouth.

She turned away, and I only ended up kissing her cheek. I looked at her with a hurt expression, and she looked down.

“I’m sorry. I’m already worked up. If you kiss me again, I don’t think I can keep myself from jumping on you. I can’t stay though. You heard him, some women and children could be hurt.”

I felt reluctant, but I knew it wasn’t fair to ask her to stay. Seeing her so sexually frustrated also was kind of cute. I was frustrated too. I already had seen how badly she wanted it. I couldn’t imagine how excited she’d be when she returned in two weeks.

“I understand. I love you.” I settled for a hug.

“I love you too,” Willow responded breathily. “You feel so good. This sucks so much.”

“It’s okay. It’s just two weeks.”

“Boo, you’re one to talk!” She puffed out her cheeks and put her hands on her hips. “You’ll just sleep with Kate in the meantime.”

“Kate and I are hardly talking, I won’t-” I was going to deny it, but I recalled I had a date with Riley too. I couldn’t lie to her and say I planned to be completely benevolent.  “Kate, I-“

Knock. Knock.

“Is everything okay?” A shout came from the other side.

“I’m still dressing!” Willow covered my mouth and shouted in a panic before whispering. “It’s fine. I knew all of that when I decided to be with you. Just stay under my bed for a little while, and then you can sneak away once I leave, okay?”

She wouldn’t let go of my mouth until I nodded. Finally, she started getting dressed and I slid back under the bed, feeling like I was a bit scummy for the first time. Having both Willow and Kate together felt like a blessing. I felt like the luckiest guy ever. Yet, with me being jealous and angry over Kate hanging with the prince, and Kate subsequently giving me the cold shoulder every time she saw the princess near me, my thoughts about it all were shifting. The polyamorous lifestyle I had dreamed of and fought for no longer felt as exciting and fulfilling as it once had.

The knight ended up bursting into the room one more time. Willow was in the process of tying up her armor. She let out a cry.

“Ah! S-sorry! I thought you were done!” He cried out, although he was checking her out.

“I’m not!” She glared back, trying to cover her body as her face turned red.

“D-do you need help?” He asked.

She shot him a glare, but then looked embarrassed. “I just… have trouble with the back.”

She turned away from him, revealing her back. Her eyes looked down at me and she mouthed an apology. I actually could see more of her body than he could, but I didn’t feel good about the situation. The man approached Willow from behind and started tying up some straps. In a short time, her outfit came together and there was nothing indecent being shown. However, this guy was seemingly alone in the room with my girl while she was barely dressed, and he even had his hands on her back.

“Ah!” She let out a cry, which nearly caused me to hit my head on the bed.

“A-are you okay?” The man asked worriedly.

“N-no.” She responded quietly. “It’s just tight.”

“It needs to be.” He responded. “If you’re armor slipped for even a bit, you might find yourself being penetrated.”

I frowned. The wording of his words felt off to me.

“Th-thanks…” Willow responded, turning back away from me after he finished. “I appreciate it, Benjamin.”

“I’m your trainer.” He responded. “It’s my job. Plus, you’re in uniform now.”

“Ah! S-sir!”

He chuckled, putting his hand on her back. “Come, let’s get a move on before they leave without us.

As he left the room and the door closed behind them, she didn’t look a single other time in my direction. Her eyes were on this man instead. His hand was touching her back too. I felt a hole in my stomach and agitation in my veins. What the hell was that about? I came to be with my girlfriend, and before I even stuck it in, she left with another man and was quite comfy.

I shook my head. I was just imagining things because I was horny and frustrated. Willow had wanted me there tonight. She was the one who got on top of me. There was no way she’d have an interest in other guys. In two weeks, when she returned, she’d be hornier than ever. In the meantime, I could patch things up with my girlfriend, and even enjoy Riley for a time.

The sudden leaving of the soldiers included several students. This woke up Ms. Diane, who started to make a fuss. The other girls ended up waking up in the confusion too. The result was that it was very late in the night when the winds had died down enough in the excitement that I felt comfortable sneaking back to my room. When I arrived, I found a note on the door. I took it and went inside.

The note didn’t say much. It was just a time and directions. Did this come from my girlfriend? Was she looking to get back together? I felt a bit of excitement return. Her sneaking out was suspicious, but it looked like she had come back around for me. Either way, the meeting was in two nights. I put the card away and finally went to sleep.

The next day, I went to the room and started doing my job once again. I managed to even get all of my meals in. The big talk of the castle was the contingent that suddenly left this morning. Along with Willow, eight other classmates left the castle on this goblin-slaying expedition. It was the first time since coming to this world that our class had separated in any meaningful way.

This separation seemed to cause anxiety in a lot of the people who stayed behind, and so they began to grow closer together. I was surprised to find many of them speaking to me. Mostly, they were curious about how I ended up in a cell and what happened. I spoke honestly about the arrow that broke in my hands. Most of them just laughed and thought it was funny. I even got a few apologies for looking down on me before.

For the first time in a long time, I felt like I was normal again. The times in the treasure room were lonely and isolating, but the times with my class almost felt like home again. The only thing lacking was the girls who were usually around me. Willow was gone, and Riley only associated with the church. Kate was always training with the prince. As for Faith, she started visiting the lunchroom regularly again, but I kept my distance from her. She had suddenly become very popular among the boys, and at any given time she had two or three classmates around her.

She had seemingly changed in a lot of ways. Where she used to feel sporty, she had a much more feminine feel. She wore dresses from this world, makeup, and did her hair. She felt like a lady from this world, but where the princess had an air of unapproachableness and refinement, she seemed inviting and sultry. The boys hung off every word and she looked genuinely happy. Once in a blue moon, our eyes would meet and she’d wink. Her transformation had left me cold.

It wasn’t long until the time in the note passed. I had already planned things out. I didn’t make the same mistake I made with Willow. I kept my eyes on the clock and got plenty of rest. Two days after being blue-balled by Willow, I was impossibly horny. When I left my room, I was jumping to go. I couldn’t wait to have makeup sex with Kate. After all, that was how this was likely to go. I’d apologize, she’d cry for a bit, and then everything would be good.

The directions were a bit difficult. This place was outside the castle in one of the hidden courtyards. Getting to it involved climbing a wall. Thankfully, with the mirror in hand, I was able to navigate perfectly. When I finally found it, it was a little herb garden hidden away between tall towers. It was a place to easily pass without ever seeing. It was beautiful in its way, with privacy and a clear view of the sky. A girl was sitting on a stool placed in the center, and my excitement grew.

However, questions formed in my mind as well. How had Kate learned about this place? It better not have been from the prince. As I climbed down some vines and landed, it suddenly occurred to me that it might not have been Kate at all. The princess could have written that letter. Why hadn’t I considered that? I wasn’t able to recognize a person’s handwriting just by seeing it, but I had just assumed it was Kate because I saw her out earlier. I began to panic.

The girl stood up as I landed, and then lifted her hood.

I blinked for a second and then smiled. “Riley.”

I was wrong, but it wasn’t a bad wrong. I was a bit sad I wasn’t making up with my girlfriend, but Riley would be a close second on who I’d want to see at night.

“Hey, Conner.” She responded, her face already slightly red.

“I got your note,” I responded. “You didn’t sign it”

“I was… just being careful.” She responded. “But you knew it was me, right?”

“Of course!” I lied. “How could it be anyone else?”

She broke into a smile. “I missed you a lot.”

I walked over and she put her arms around me and hugged me. Unlike Willow, she was very soft. If anything, she had grown softer. Her skin was milky and smooth and her hair was silky and smelled of berries. The priesthood did hold the market for beauty items.

“Why did you ask me here?” I asked after we hugged for a while.

“Are you going to make me say it?” She asked into my shirt. “I-I’m ready.”

I let out a long breath, pushing down the excitement that made me want to shove her to the ground and fuck her brains out. Riley was still a virgin, so I had to do things correctly. That’s part of the reason I wished it had been my girlfriend. I was so worked up that I just needed to let loose. Kate and I had been together enough that I wouldn’t embarrass myself. She understood that every encounter couldn’t be the best there ever was.

However, the time was now. I leaned forward to kiss Riley, but she put a finger up, stopping me mid-kiss.

“Mwhat?” I asked through her finger.

“You have to promise me something though,” Riley stated. “You can… um… finish anywhere… but not inside.”

“Huh?”

She blushed. “That’s the rule. After my purification ceremony, I will be a priestess. I asked around very carefully. I don’t have to be a virgin, but that said a man’s seed can’t meet with my womb.”

I took her finger off my mouth and then kissed it gently. “That’s no problem.”

I had pulled out with Kate many times. This was no different. Those words seemed to cut Riley’s cord, and she melted into me. I kissed her a bit more passionately, and unlike earlier with Willow, my dick came to full erection.

Riley did try to make her first and allegedly only time special. She picked the perfect time and the perfect place. This isolated courtyard took on a fantasy feel, especially since the sky was from another world. I gently began to pull off her dress, all the while kissing her soft, white skin. As more of her body was bared, it seemed to glow in the moonlight. Riley’s untouched body was perfect. She had a large chest, and wide hips, and she seemed soft in every way that mattered.

I laid out a blanket I had brought with me and then laid her down on it. Her face was flushed and she was already breathing hard. As for myself, I could barely hold back. It had been days, and after being blue-balled, I desperately wanted release. This tempting untouched flower was begging for it, and I was going to give it to her.

Her dress had pooled around her waist and her legs were spread for me. I moved between them and felt myself touching the warmest place on her body. Riley was completely bare underneath, and I made the mistake of looking between her legs. It was obvious she was inexperienced, but she still had a hint of a wet pussy. I would have to make this good for her.

I began to kiss and suck at Riley’s breasts, letting my hands drift over her skin. She seemed to enjoy that, so I continued to massage her. My lips trailed down her stomach and across her thighs. Riley kept trying to close her legs and cover herself up, but she forced herself to be exposed, giving herself to me despite her usual instincts.

I could feel the heat of her sex against my cheek and I used my fingers to spread her open. I kissed the inside of her thighs and made sure she felt my tongue. Riley’s breathing got deeper and she whimpered slightly as I neared her pussy. It was tight and untouched and soaking wet. She let out a little cry when I finally reached her pussy. My tongue dipped in between her lips, tasting her sweet nectar.

“Mmmm…” She moaned, and the sound was ecstasy in my ear.

I wanted to foreplay more, to bring her closer and closer, but I had already wasted all of my patience earlier with Willow. My dick was rock hard and I couldn’t hold back. I slid my pants down and placed the tip at the entrance of Riley’s pussy.

“Oh… Conner…” she whispered, realizing what was happening.

“Are you ready?” I asked, even as I slowly pressed forward.

Riley started to shake her head, but I was too horny to wait. Her body was so tight and warm that I needed to be inside of it. The head of my cock went into her and she let out a cry. I couldn’t wait, and I started to push myself into her more and more.

“O-ow….” she cried, her hands tightening on my arms.

Feeling it squeeze against me so tightly was pure euphoria. It had been months since I last tasted a virgin pussy in that of Willow, and that was when I was still getting it regularly from my girlfriend. Now that I was on a dry spell, it felt amazing. I pushed in harder and harder. Her nails dug into my arms, but she took my whole cock in one violent stroke.

“I’m in!” I announced happily.

“Haaah… haha… it hurts.” Riley cried.

“You’ll like it soon, I promise,” I responded eager, pulling out and pushing in again.

I looked down to see my bloodied cock sliding in and out of her. I was a bit surprised. With my previous girls, there had been very little blood. This time, there seemed to be quite a lot. However, it seemed to act like lubricant making it easier to pull in and out, so I went ahead and used it and started to move my hips. It felt so good, I couldn’t stop myself.

“Ahh… ahhh…” She moaned every time I slid into her, her face scrunched up in pain.

“Your pussy is amazing,” I told her excitedly. “You feel so good.”

“Mm…hmmm… aaahh..” She tried to validate me before letting out another cry.

Her hands were losing energy though, and her moans were sounding less and less pained. Her body was so soft and she was so tight. Before I even realized it, I was cumming. I shook as much load shot into her. I held myself there for a moment. Riley slowly recovered and opened her eyes. She looked up at me with tears.

“I-is it over?” She asked.

I finally remembered that I wasn’t supposed to cum inside her. However, she didn’t seem to notice, either because of the blood or because of inexperience.

I shook my head. “I’m going to cum soon.”

She nodded. “Please, just anywhere but inside.”

I felt a little bad, but I was still incredibly horny. She was so tight that I hadn’t lost any wood, and once I started pushing it in and out again my cock regained its hardness. I continued to push in her, pretending I couldn’t feel the white gunk sloshing around every time I pushed inside her.

“Hah… ahh…” Her voice sounded less pained now. “Conner… it does feel… good.”

“Ahhh!” I pulled out without a second to spare.

I shot a second load. This one went right up her stomach. I shot a few streaks up there, and then finally leaned back on my knees. She looked down at the mess I left on her stomach, and she made a weird face.

“What?” I asked, putting my dick, still bloody, away.

“N-nothing.” She responded, “I just didn’t realize it was so messy.”

“You’re the reason it’s messy!” I shot back. “You bled all over my blanket!”

She looked away, an expression of shame on her face. “S-sorry, I didn’t mean to.”

I let out a sigh. “It’s fine. You okay?”

“I’m fine, it hurt at first, but you were right, it started to feel better in the end. It was over a bit quick though…”

“It gets better the more you do it!” I protested, not even wanting to explain my quickness.

She smiled sadly. “I won’t get to do it again.”

“That!” I held up my hand. “Um, we can do it again now.”

I’d rather not. It feels sore.”

“Tomorrow then!”

She shook her head sadly. “I think this is the last time we’ll be able to meet before my purification ceremony. You’ll be there for that though, won’t you?”

I nodded. “I will!”

She smiled. “Then, I’m happy.”

“Y-you sure?” I asked, reaching out to touch her again.

“Yeah, I’m fine. Just lie with me.” She pulled me down next to her.

We lay like that for a few hours under the moon. I wanted to go again with her, but she already had said no once and I didn’t want to force the issue. I eventually fell asleep, and the next morning I woke up in the courtyard alone. It was morning, and I had to make my way back to my room without being seen. I had gotten better and better at using the mirror though, and I was able to get inside and get cleaned up. The only problem was the bloody blanket. There was nothing I could do about it without making it obvious what I had done.

At least, things seemed to finally be going well. I could have never guessed what kind of nightmare I had awaiting me.

The time has come for me to join the church tonight. The ceremony is at sunset. I’m allowed to bring a witness. Will you agree?

She didn’t sign it, but I knew this message came from Riley. A few days had passed since we had sex. I hadn’t been able to talk to her since, and I was a bit worried that I hurt her feelings. My feelings had been bundled up in such knots that I hadn’t even much of Kate who still wasn’t talking to me or Willow who had gone off to fight goblins. I had mostly stuck to my time in treasury taking inventory of magical artifacts.

That’s when returning to my room after dinner, I found another note. After reading it, I couldn’t help but tense slightly. It felt in a lot of ways like I was losing Riley forever. Our relationship had only just begun to blossom, but now she was going to make some claim to celibacy and become a permanent member of the church. Of course, I didn’t want to leave things like that, so I checked outside. She had waited until the last moment to tell me, as the sun was already starting to set.

“Oh!” I blinked, and then also blushed. “You won’t get any pleasure though…”

“That might not be true…” She spoke sheepishly. “One of the other priestesses drank too much wine and she accidentally revealed that she has a boyfriend. Since she can’t let him inside her female parts, she found pleasure in letting him inside her… other holes.”

“Other hole?” I asked before it struck me. “Oh!”

“After the ceremony… we-we could… try it?” She offered.

I felt my horniness returning, along with a good bit of excitement. I had barely taken Riley’s cherry, and now she was offering me her ass? How could I not be excited?

“Initiate! It is time!” I deep voice came from the church before I could respond.

She took a deep breath. “Okay, it’s time. Please watch.”

“I-I will!” I declared with assuredness, feeling much better than I had in weeks.

She smiled one more time, and then opened the door and walked out. I joined her, finding a seat in the front pew. I was close enough that I could see all the frowning priests clearly, but I ignored them. There was no way I wasn’t going to witness Riley become a priestess. After that, I was going to enjoy her ass!

The ceremony began, and I made sure to keep my dick under control as I watched Riley stand in the front of the room. The lead priest was a bald man with bushy eyebrows and a severe expression on his face. He walked over and handed her a small dagger, and she held it in both her hands.

Then, the priest began to speak.

“Our Goddess, who watches over us from the heavens, and blesses us with your gifts of love and fertility. You give life and love, and ask nothing more than that we worship you. We pray to you on this day to accept this young woman and her offer of service. She has dedicated her life to you and will serve in any capacity you need, until the day she dies. We beseech you, goddess, to accept her offer and allow her into your divine graces, so that she may be forever blessed.”

“I offer myself, mind, body, and soul to the goddess,” Riley answered.

The priest stepped back, and Riley placed the dagger over her palm, and then, without flinching, she sliced it open. Her blood welled up and dripped onto the ground. I almost stood up, but I managed to resist myself. It may seem barbaric, but this appeared to be what she expected.

A priest came up with a chalice, and then she dripped her blood on it. He handed her a napkin that she pressed down to stop the bleeding. He then lifted the chalice into the air and continued to speak.

“With this chalice, and her blood, the young initiate has made her offering. She has given her body, her mind, and her blood. We pray, goddess, that you will accept this offering.”

The priest then took the offering back to the altar, and he poured various unmarked bottles into it. When he was done, he walked back and handed it to the girl.

“Our goddess, it is time for your judgment. She drinks of your blood. If she is pure, let her pass into your loving embrace.”

With that, Riley took the chalice to her lips and began to drink it. After gulping it down, she suddenly let out a cough. She coughed several times, and the last time was so strong she lost her grip on the chalice and it fell to the floor. The rest of the red liquid splashed out on the floor.

The priest winced, looking away with regret. “She is impure.”

She continued to cough until she was on the ground, each cough sounding hoarser and worse than the last. I finally got out of my seat and ran to her, grabbing her. She was still coughing, looking up at me with confusion and fear.

“What’s going on?” I demanded. “What do you mean, impure? What did you do to her?”

The man looked at me and sneered. “Her womb has been contaminated by a man. The drink she took opens her to the almighty. If she was pure, she would have communed with the goddess. Instead, she only allowed demons into her body.”

“Demons? What demons?” I demanded.

Riley had stopped coughing, and her face started to turn red. “Hot… so hot…”

I touched her forehead and then cried out. “She’s burning up!”

“She’s dying.” He sighed. “The demons are in her soul.”

“What? Seriously?” I asked in a panic. “You can’t save her? There has to be something… anything…”

The priests all exchanged looks, a few of them grinning.

“If she is to survive, she must go through the purification ceremony. Once we purify her, she will never be able to leave the church again. She will require nightly purifications. We are willing to do it, but her loved one must consent. Many claim to prefer death.”

“Well, I’m not one of them! Do it!” I cried out in a panic. “Save her!”

“If you insist.” His face twisted as he reached down to grab her with the other priests.

“So… hot…” She panted, and I finally got a good look at her face as they lifted her.

She didn’t seem sick. her face looked slightly perverted. She was panting and the rosiness in her cheeks gave off something other than fear or discomfort.

“As the priesthood, we promise to purge this woman of all of her demons. We will quell her desires and ease her suffering, with our dicks!”

As he finished, I stared in absolute shock as the six priests around her all pulled out their dicks from their robes. Every single one of them was hard like they had been waiting for this. Now, they wore perverted looks on their faces as they looked down at Riley like a slab of meat. Had I not already seen something like this with Faith, I wouldn’t have known what I was looking at. However, I wasn’t the same fool anymore.

I ran forward to grab her, but that’s when two large priests grabbed me. As I tried to fight back, they slugged me in the stomach. I collapsed to the ground, coughing, as the lead priest held his dick to Riley’s face.

“The only way to fight through your demons is to satiate them. Come, lost soul, seek your release.”

The panting Riley looked over at his dick. Instead of looking in revulsion, she licked her lips. Then, before my eyes, I saw my pure virgin Riley start to suck on another man’s dick. She started timidly, but as he thrust, she started to take his dick more enthusiastically. As Riley sucked his dick, the other priests cut off her beautiful silk dress with the knife she had cut herself with earlier.

Soon, her body I had been the only one to see naked was being shown to all of these men. Riley barely even seemed to care she was stripped naked. She was aggressively sucking his dick now. Meanwhile, she had her legs spread and she was fingering herself frantically while moaning against his dick. I struggled again but the two men forced me down into the chair and then started tying me to it.

“Stay a while, enjoy the show.” One of the priests grinned at me. “It’s not every day we get to do a purification ceremony. It’s the only time we’re permitted to use our dicks. The last fallen priestess committed suicide a few months ago, so it’s been a while.”

He began pinching Riley’s nipples, causing her to let out little squeaks and moans as she pleasured the lead priest.

“You’re lucky you got to enjoy her once. She was the prettiest priestess we’ve recruited in a long time. It’s a shame you contaminated her, but I bet we can turn her into a good slave.”

“Slave?!” I cried out.

“Oh yes. Do you think she can ever go home after this? Once she becomes our plaything, she can’t leave. She’ll have to become a whore for the church, just like the other fallen.”

“You bastard! You did this on purpose!”

The priest laughed as he put his member in Riley’s hand. “If she remained pure, she would have been a priestess. Don’t blame us.”

Riley didn’t hesitate to start jacking him off. My mind tried to make sense of what I was seeing. Had I caused this? Was it because I came in here and broke the tenants? Was she filled with demons controlling her body? My body was racked with pain, guilt, and confusion as I watched the loving girl who offered her anal virginity to me a short moment ago suddenly turn into a slut for a bunch of priests.

“I always wanted to taste a girl from another world.” One of the priests chuckled, lowering his head between her legs.

Her hand that was frantically masturbating was pulled away and another dick was placed in it. Meanwhile, a somewhat ugly-looking fat guy started licking her pussy. Riley moaned in euphoria even while jacking two guys and sucking a third off. Her entire body shivered.

“That’s it, girl.” Another priest cooed. “You’re doing so well. Your pussy tastes good. You’ll make a great slave.”

The priest’s comments seemed to be affecting Riley. She became more eager and more excited, and her moans got louder. Meanwhile, the man eating her out started fingering her, which caused her to cum.

“Oh god!” She cried, spitting out the cock she had been sucking and saying the first words I had heard from her.

“Riley, don’t succumb to them!” I cried out.

She looked my way and then looked down ashamed.

“Well girl, what do you have to say?” The lead priest asks, a mocking expression on his face.

“C-cock…” She spoke so quietly I almost didn’t hear her.

“What was that?” The priest asked.

“I want… I want cock!” She moaned.

The priest eating her out let out a laugh. “This one is the sluttiest we’ve gotten so far. Most of the girls at least try to deny it.”

“Don’t worry, fallen priestess, you’ll have all the cock you want!” The lead priest laughed.

As soon as the words left his mouth, the priests swarmed her and turned her around so she was on all fours. One of the priests got in front of her and she started sucking his dick, not caring it was a different guy than the one before. The priests all had their hands on her body, touching squeezing, and pinching. They spread her open, making sure her asshole and pussy were in full view. The head priest brought his dick up to her pussy, still soaked from her previous sucking, and pressed the head against the lips of her cunt.

“You want me to fuck you?” He asked.

She shook her head excitedly even while sucking cock like it was all she could think about. I could see from here she was extremely horny. She was wet to the point of dripping. I could even smell the scent that I recognized from a few nights higher. It didn’t make any sense. How did my precious lover suddenly turn into a slut just like that? Were there demons at play? That’s when I remembered the aphrodisiac that Faith had been making.

That’s when it call clicked. The drink they gave her must have been filled with some kind of aphrodisiac. They had planned this from the beginning. They probably took every pretty girl joining the priestesses and failed them, turning them into a fallen priestess they could play with every night. However, realizing it wasn’t my fault didn’t make me feel an ounce better. The priest began to fuck her right in front of me.