Chapter 12

The time has come for me to join the church tonight. The ceremony is at sunset. I’m allowed to bring a witness. Will you agree?

She didn’t sign it, but I knew this message came from Riley. A few days had passed since we had sex. I hadn’t been able to talk to her since, and I was a bit worried that I hurt her feelings. My feelings had been bundled up in such knots that I hadn’t even thought much of Kate who still wasn’t talking to me or Willow who had gone off to fight goblins. I had mostly stuck to my time in treasury taking inventory of magical artifacts.

That’s when returning to my room after dinner, I found another note. After reading it, I couldn’t help but tense slightly. It felt in a lot of ways like I was losing Riley forever. Our relationship had only just begun to blossom, but now she was going to make some claim to celibacy and become a permanent member of the church. Of course, I didn’t want to leave things like that, so I checked outside. She had waited until the last moment to tell me, as the sun was already starting to set. I decided to set out.

Thankfully, the mirror made everything really easy. I was becoming a pro at traveling around at night. As I navigated the hallways, I was able to avoid any unwanted eyes. I saw the princess once, but I was able to give her the slip. She actually hadn’t tried to talk to me since I had been imprisoned. Perhaps she given up her pursuit.

Or maybe her brother had already gotten what he wanted from Kate.

I couldn’t help but hear those bitter inner voices. However, I wasn’t going to think about Kate tonight. This was Riley’s night. Riley was the one who rescued me from that prison. Riley gave me her virginity. Riley made all of these sacrifices! As I reached the front of the church. I couldn’t help but let out a melancholy sigh. Maybe, Riley should have been my girlfriend after all, but now, it was too late.

“I just wished we could still be together after tonight.” I spoke out loud.

“We can be.”

I jumped as a voice came out of the darkness. I squinted to see Riley emerge, causing me to let out a relieved sigh.

“Riley… wait, what do you mean?”

She smiled sheepishly. “I’ve definately been asking around, and apparantly there are always workarounds to the church laws.”

“R-really?”

“For example… I’ve never given a blowjob before.” She turned adorably red.

“Ah… but you won’t feel any pleasure…” I felt dumb as soon as I said it.

“That might not be true…” She spoke sheepishly. “One of the other priestesses drank too much wine and she accidentally revealed that she has a boyfriend. Since she can’t let him inside her female parts, she found pleasure in letting him inside her… other holes.”

“Other hole?” I asked before it struck me. “Oh!”

“After the ceremony… we-we could… try it?” She offered.

I felt my horniness returning, along with a good bit of excitement. I had barely taken Riley’s cherry, and now she was offering me her ass? How could I not be excited?

“Initiate! It is time!” I deep voice came from the church before I could respond.

She took a deep breath. “Okay, it’s time. Please watch.”

“I-I will!” I declared with assuredness, feeling much better than I had in weeks.

She smiled one more time, and then opened the door and walked out. I joined her, finding a seat in the front pew. I was close enough that I could see all the frowning priests clearly, but I ignored them. There was no way I wasn’t going to witness Riley become a priestess. After that, I was going to enjoy her ass!

The ceremony began, and I made sure to keep my dick under control as I watched Riley stand in the front of the room. The lead priest was a bald man with bushy eyebrows and a severe expression on his face. He walked over and handed her a small dagger, and she held it in both her hands.

Then, the priest began to speak.

“Our Goddess, who watches over us from the heavens, and blesses us with your gifts of love and fertility. You give life and love, and ask nothing more than that we worship you. We pray to you on this day to accept this young woman and her offer of service. She has dedicated her life to you and will serve in any capacity you need, until the day she dies. We beseech you, goddess, to accept her offer and allow her into your divine graces, so that she may be forever blessed.”

“I offer myself, mind, body, and soul to the goddess,” Riley answered.

The priest stepped back, and Riley placed the dagger over her palm, and then, without flinching, she sliced it open. Her blood welled up and dripped onto the ground. I almost stood up, but I managed to resist myself. It may seem barbaric, but this appeared to be what she expected.

A priest came up with a chalice, and then she dripped her blood on it. He handed her a napkin that she pressed down to stop the bleeding. He then lifted the chalice into the air and continued to speak.

“With this chalice, and her blood, the young initiate has made her offering. She has given her body, her mind, and her blood. We pray, goddess, that you will accept this offering.”

The priest then took the offering back to the altar, and he poured various unmarked bottles into it. When he was done, he walked back and handed it to the girl.

“Our goddess, it is time for your judgment. She drinks of your blood. If she is pure, let her pass into your loving embrace.”

With that, Riley took the chalice to her lips and began to drink it. After gulping it down, she suddenly let out a cough. She coughed several times, and the last time was so strong she lost her grip on the chalice and it fell to the floor. The rest of the red liquid splashed out on the floor.

The priest winced, looking away with regret. “She is impure.”

She continued to cough until she was on the ground, each cough sounding hoarser and worse than the last. I finally got out of my seat and ran to her, grabbing her. She was still coughing, looking up at me with confusion and fear.

“What’s going on?” I demanded. “What do you mean, impure? What did you do to her?”

The man looked at me and sneered. “Her womb has been contaminated by a man. The drink she took opens her to the almighty. If she was pure, she would have communed with the goddess. Instead, she only allowed demons into her body.”

“Demons? What demons?” I demanded.

Riley had stopped coughing, and her face started to turn red. “Hot… so hot…”

I touched her forehead and then cried out. “She’s burning up!”

“She’s dying.” He sighed. “The demons are in her soul.”

“What? Seriously?” I asked in a panic. “You can’t save her? There has to be something… anything…”

The priests all exchanged looks, a few of them grinning.

“If she is to survive, she must go through the purification ceremony. Once we purify her, she will never be able to leave the church again. She will require nightly purifications. We are willing to do it, but her loved one must consent. Many claim to prefer death.”

“Well, I’m not one of them! Do it!” I cried out in a panic. “Save her!”

“If you insist.” His face twisted as he reached down to grab her with the other priests.

“So… hot…” She panted, and I finally got a good look at her face as they lifted her.

She didn’t seem sick. her face looked slightly perverted. She was panting and the rosiness in her cheeks gave off something other than fear or discomfort.

“As the priesthood, we promise to purge this woman of all of her demons. We will quell her desires and ease her suffering, with our dicks!”

As he finished, I stared in absolute shock as the six priests around her all pulled out their dicks from their robes. Every single one of them was hard like they had been waiting for this. Now, they wore perverted looks on their faces as they looked down at Riley like a slab of meat. Had I not already seen something like this with Faith, I wouldn’t have known what I was looking at. However, I wasn’t the same fool anymore.

I ran forward to grab her, but that’s when two large priests grabbed me. As I tried to fight back, they slugged me in the stomach. I collapsed to the ground, coughing, as the lead priest held his dick to Riley’s face.

“The only way to fight through your demons is to satiate them. Come, lost soul, seek your release.”

The panting Riley looked over at his dick. Instead of looking in revulsion, she licked her lips. Then, before my eyes, I saw my pure virgin Riley start to suck on another man’s dick. She started timidly, but as he thrust, she started to take his dick more enthusiastically. As Riley sucked his dick, the other priests cut off her beautiful silk dress with the knife she had cut herself with earlier.

Soon, her body I had been the only one to see naked was being shown to all of these men. Riley barely even seemed to care she was stripped naked. She was aggressively sucking his dick now. Meanwhile, she had her legs spread and she was fingering herself frantically while moaning against his dick. I struggled again but the two men forced me down into the chair and then started tying me to it.

“Stay a while, enjoy the show.” One of the priests grinned at me. “It’s not every day we get to do a purification ceremony. It’s the only time we’re permitted to use our dicks. The last fallen priestess committed suicide a few months ago, so it’s been a while.”

He began pinching Riley’s nipples, causing her to let out little squeaks and moans as she pleasured the lead priest.

“You’re lucky you got to enjoy her once. She was the prettiest priestess we’ve recruited in a long time. It’s a shame you contaminated her, but I bet we can turn her into a good slave.”

“Slave?!” I cried out.

“Oh yes. Do you think she can ever go home after this? Once she becomes our plaything, she can’t leave. She’ll have to become a whore for the church, just like the other fallen.”

“You bastard! You did this on purpose!”

The priest laughed as he put his member in Riley’s hand. “If she remained pure, she would have been a priestess. Don’t blame us.”

Riley didn’t hesitate to start jacking him off. My mind tried to make sense of what I was seeing. Had I caused this? Was it because I came in here and broke the tenants? Was she filled with demons controlling her body? My body was racked with pain, guilt, and confusion as I watched the loving girl who offered her anal virginity to me a short moment ago suddenly turn into a slut for a bunch of priests.

“I always wanted to taste a girl from another world.” One of the priests chuckled, lowering his head between her legs.

Her hand that was frantically masturbating was pulled away and another dick was placed in it. Meanwhile, a somewhat ugly-looking fat guy started licking her pussy. Riley moaned in euphoria even while jacking two guys and sucking a third off. Her entire body shivered.

“That’s it, girl.” Another priest cooed. “You’re doing so well. Your pussy tastes good. You’ll make a great slave.”

The priest’s comments seemed to be affecting Riley. She became more eager and more excited, and her moans got louder. Meanwhile, the man eating her out started fingering her, which caused her to cum.

“Oh god!” She cried, spitting out the cock she had been sucking and saying the first words I had heard from her.

“Riley, don’t succumb to them!” I cried out.

She looked my way and then looked down ashamed.

“Well girl, what do you have to say?” The lead priest asks, a mocking expression on his face.

“C-cock…” She spoke so quietly I almost didn’t hear her.

“What was that?” The priest asked.

“I want… I want cock!” She moaned.

The priest eating her out let out a laugh. “This one is the sluttiest we’ve gotten so far. Most of the girls at least try to deny it.”

“Don’t worry, fallen priestess, you’ll have all the cock you want!” The lead priest laughed.

As soon as the words left his mouth, the priests swarmed her and turned her around so she was on all fours. One of the priests got in front of her and she started sucking his dick, not caring it was a different guy than the one before. The priests all had their hands on her body, touching squeezing, and pinching. They spread her open, making sure her asshole and pussy were in full view. The head priest brought his dick up to her pussy, still soaked from her previous sucking, and pressed the head against the lips of her cunt.

“You want me to fuck you?” He asked.

She shook her head excitedly even while sucking cock like it was all she could think about. I could see from here she was extremely horny. She was wet to the point of dripping. I could even smell the scent that I recognized from a few nights higher. It didn’t make any sense. How did my precious lover suddenly turn into a slut just like that? Were there demons at play? That’s when I remembered the aphrodisiac that Faith had been making.

That’s when it all clicked. The drink they gave her must have been filled with some kind of aphrodisiac. They had planned this from the beginning. They probably took every pretty girl joining the priestesses and failed them, turning them into a fallen priestess they could play with every night. However, realizing it wasn’t my fault didn’t make me feel an ounce better. The priest began to fuck her right in front of me.