Chapter 13

“I want… I want cock!” She moaned.

The priest eating her out let out a laugh. “This one is the sluttiest we’ve gotten so far. Most of the girls at least try to deny it.”

“Don’t worry, fallen priestess, you’ll have all the cock you want!” The lead priest laughed.

As soon as the words left his mouth, the priests swarmed her and turned her around so she was on all fours. One of the priests got in front of her and she started sucking his dick, not caring it was a different guy than the one before. The priests all had their hands on her body, touching squeezing, and pinching. They spread her open, making sure her asshole and pussy were in full view. The head priest brought his dick up to her pussy, still soaked from her previous sucking, and pressed the head against the lips of her cunt.

“You want me to fuck you?” He asked.

She shook her head excitedly even while sucking cock like it was all she could think about. I could see from here she was extremely horny. She was wet to the point of dripping. I could even smell the scent that I recognized from a few nights higher. It didn’t make any sense. How did my precious lover suddenly turn into a slut just like that? Were there demons at play? That’s when I remembered the aphrodisiac that Faith had been making.

That’s when it all clicked. The drink they gave her must have been filled with some kind of aphrodisiac. They had planned this from the beginning. They probably took every pretty girl joining the priestesses and failed them, turning them into a fallen priestess they could play with every night. However, realizing it wasn’t my fault didn’t make me feel an ounce better. The priest began to fuck her right in front of me.

I struggled desperately against my restraints. It was all happening again. This was just like what happened with my sister. I couldn’t believe it was happening again to Riley, and I couldn’t do anything. No, things were different this time. While Riley was on some kind of aphrodisiac, I wasn’t! My head was completely clear.

“Stop this!” I shouted.

The head priest looked down at me with a laugh. “She’s a fallen priestess. She’s chosen to fall into depravity rather than live her life serving the goddess. Now, she needs to repent. I think this is the perfect lesson, don’t you?”

“Fuck you!” I cursed.

I continued to struggle as the priest fucked her. All the while she had a huge, stupid smile on her face as she sucked the cock in front of her. The two were fucking her like she was no better than a toy, only there for their pleasure. I was so mad I could hardly see. However, the thing that pissed me off the most is that Riley was enjoying it. She wasn’t screaming or crying for help. She was acting like a slut who wanted nothing more than to get fucked. Even my sister tried to resist at first.

The head priest fucked her until he came inside of her. I watched the cum dribble out of her pussy as he pulled out. Another priest stepped up and slid inside her pussy, fucking her like the head priest had done. He finished inside of her and let his cum dribble out of her pussy, mixing with the previous priest. They then made her roll around, so she was lying on her back. She spread her legs open, her pussy gaping as it leaked white stuff. However, as a priest push his cock to her mouth, she seemed to have noticed me for the first time.

“Wait a second, guys.” She held up her hands, and the priests stopped, still holding and stroking their dicks. “Why is Connor tied up?”

The head priest glanced over at me and laughed. “He was getting a little too excited, so he can’t join the purification ceremony.”

She looked disappointed. “Connor, you don’t want to fuck me?”

“Wh-what?” I asked in shock.

Her voice was too normal. It didn’t sound like she was under aphrodisiacs at all!

“This is the purification ceremony. Remember? I have to be purified of my demons.”

I blinked, my brain feeling like it had been struck with a brick. “Th-they said you were impure though.”

“I know… that’s why I’m being purified!” She declared.

“Purified with what?” I demanded.

“Semen!” She smiled. “Semen is the purest form of humanity that exists.”

“B-but… they said you’d be their slave and plaything…”

The priests all broke into laughter. “We call that a joke.”

“Huh?” I stared at them all dumbly.

“You gentlemen continue with the purification ceremony. I’ll speak with the boy.” The head priest nodded and walked over to me.

As he did so, the other priests all began to circle Riley. She grabbed two cocks, one in each hand, and then put another in her mouth as a fourth put it between her legs. No sooner did they start than she was writhing and moaning in ecstasy.

“What the hell…” I mumbled.

“The skin cosmetics she’s been wearing increase her sensitivity.” The head priest explained.

“So, you did drug her!”

He chuckled. “She knew what they would do to her. Just like she knew that spending a night with you would mean she needed a more aggressive purification. Normally, it only needs three priests, but since you mix blood and semen, she needed twice as many.”

“I-I don’t understand…”

“It’s our church doctrine. To become a priest, one must withhold from intercourse. Doing so makes our semen holy.”

“It doesn’t look like you’re withholding!” I snapped as a priest began to moan, white spurtings shooting out onto Riley’s beautiful tits.

“This is a purification ceremony. To make a woman pure, priests must unload their purifying semen all over her body. Once this has happened, he is a priestess. However, it is sacrilegious to mix semen with vaginal blood. So, we can’t have sex with two types of women… those on their periods and…”

“Virgins,” I spoke in realization. “A-are you saying… that the only reason Riley came to me was so I’d take her virginity so she could be purified?”

“Connor, it’s not as bad as you think.” Riley sat up, but she was still stroking two cocks, one in each hand. “I do like you a lot. Of every guy in the castle, I wanted you to be my first. I did ask the church to help you out of the dungeon. The cost was I had to become a priestess. I’m becoming a priest now. Can’t you be happy for me? Ahh!”

She cried as one of the priests started to suck on her nipples, although she then giggled, shaking her chest in his face. My scalp itched, and I didn’t even know how to respond.

“As for the thing about fallen priestesses… they do exist, these are women who choose to leave the church for a man. We were a bit afraid you might take our recruit away. We all rather like Riley, you see…”

“Ahhh…” She giggled, getting off the pedestal, “I like you all too. Now, who wants me to fuck them on top!”

She sat on a cock, sliding herself down. As she began to bounce, she grabbed a cock in each hand and began to stroke, and a priest stood in front of her, slapping his cock against her face and sticking his balls in her mouth. Her boobs bounced up and down as she rode the cock, never stopping even as she licked the cock in her face.

“Fuck, she’s a great little slut.” The head priest complimented her.

“She’s a natural.” Another priest laughed. “Look at how easily she’s taking all that cock.”

“I can’t believe she was a virgin last night.” The priest in her mouth laughed.

The head priest turned to me. “I know you have a thing for sluts, and Riley is the biggest one of them all. You can be her boyfriend, but she belongs to the church now. And as long as she is, her pussy will be open to any priest who needs her. Understand?”

Riley was moaning. “Fuck me. Oh yeah. Fuck me. I love your cocks. They’re so good! Fuck! Fuck!”

I watched, unable to move or do anything but watch as Riley got fucked. A priest came inside her pussy, then she switched to another, and another, and another. Every priest fucked her pussy and came inside of her. They fucked her all over, on her back, on her knees, on her stomach, even holding her in the air. They fucked her until the room was filled with the sounds of moaning and the smell of sex. Riley’s skin shined with sweat. Eventually, the priests finished, leaving her on the ground, covered in cum. She was a mess, her body smeared in cum and her pussy leaking.

The head priest came to me with a smile and cut my ropes. I jumped up and ran to her. She was breathing hard, too tired to get up. Her body was warm to the touch.

“Riley… I’m so sorry…” I felt guilty that I couldn’t protect her from this.

“Ha… ahh… that was amazing…” She smiled, opening her eyes.

I was shocked to see she was coherent.

“Riley… are you ok?” I asked.

She gave me a big, sweet smile. “Connor… that was the best. I’ve never felt so pure in my life. The priests are so big and powerful… they make me see god.”

“This…”

“I know this might be a bit much. I’ll admit when I came the first day and learned about the church, I was skeptical, but the head priest showed me all kinds of wonders. He made my body feel such magical things. Even when I resisted, he never gave up on me, and now I’m finally one with the church.” As she spoke, I began to see an unhinged look in her eyes.

I had seen a documentary once. It was talking about some crazy death cult. One of the members who had bought into the entire thing had been interviewed. His eyes reminded me of Riley’s eyes at that moment. I closed my eyes. She had already been brainwashed by the church. While I had been focused on my sister, Riley had been getting similar treatment, although while one girl’s mind was broken, the other just bought their whole crazy religion.

I sighed. “I’m sorry.”

“There is nothing to be sorry about.” She reached out and pinched me, causing me to open my eyes. “Connor, you know, there still is one who hasn’t purified me. I want you… to finish me off.”

She smiled so sweetly, but her eyes were completely hollow. Why didn’t I notice before? I felt cold on the inside. Yet, when she reached out and grabbed my crotch, I realized I was rock hard. After seeing her violated by those priests, my body was still aroused. What was wrong with me? First, my sister, and now my friend.

As if I was functioning automatically, I unzipped my pants and pulled out my dick. I then grabbed Riley’s legs and pulled her to the edge of the altar. I looked down at her pussy, once a perfect slit, now slightly agape and leaking the white cum of various men. My lips tightened, and I shoved my dick into her.

“Mm…” She smiled. “Yes, Connor, purify me!”

I didn’t say anything. My body moved on its own. I spread her legs apart, using them for leverage. I began to thrust into her, fucking her hard and fast. I couldn’t look away from her face, which had become a mask of lust. She was panting like a dog in heat. This was the girl who had come to me for the first time. Now she was a complete whore.

“Fuck me, Connor. Fuck me!” She begged.

I fucked her harder, pulling her legs up until she was bent in half, her legs over my shoulders. My dick was going deep, just as deep as every other priest before me. I felt her pussy tighten around me as she came, moaning loudly. I felt something in me snap, and I started to fuck her harder. She cried out, her moans echoing through the room. I leaned down to kiss her, and that’s when I noticed little drops of water falling on her face. She looked up at me, cocking her head.

“Why are you crying?” She asked in a pant.

It was because I suddenly felt extremely sad. I didn’t answer her though.  I fucked her harder, trying to hold in my sobs. I couldn’t stand to see her this way, to hear her talking like that while being fucked. I felt like I was going to throw up.

“Come on, Connor. Cum inside me.” She whispered in my ear.

I couldn’t take anymore. I pushed deep into her, my cock throbbing as I came inside her. She cried out, arching her back as her pussy tightened around me, milking me for every drop. I fell forward onto her, my head on her tits. She wrapped her arms around me and held me close.

“Good boy…” She patted my head. “I’m pure.”

My body shook with sobs, but I couldn’t make a sound. I just laid there, letting her hold me. Meanwhile, priests were watching us from every angle. When I finished, I stood up, feeling like my entire soul had been scooped out.

“I’ll be leaving then,” I told her, my voice with no emotion.

She giggled. “You know where to find me. Don’t forget… my ass is still available.”

I nodded and then walked away. As I reached the door, I heard the high priest.

“How was it?”

“I barely felt anything with him.” She responded.

“That’s because he’s tainted. His semen mixed with blood and he releases for any woman. Only priests can bring you greater pleasure.”

“Please… pleasure me.” She whimpered.

The door to the church closed, and I was on the outside.